Even as the Congress-led UPA government is out to woo the aam-aadmi amid talks of a possible mid-term poll by extending the rural job guarantee scheme to the entire country, doubts have been raised by the government itself and its National Advisory Council (NAC). The National Rural Employment Guarantee Act (NREGA) of the government has been one of the most successful populist measures announced by the UPA government which has provided employment of over 2.1 crore man-days across 330 districts across the country.

However, according to the government?s own admission, states like Uttar Pradesh, Jharkhand, Orrisa amongst others have not lived up to delivering the designed goal of the NREGA. There has been mixed reaction from the people over the scheme?s implementation, with non-payment of wages being the most common grievance.

?There is little difference between the NREGA and earlier employment programmes? the basic purpose of providing employment on demand, at the statutory minimum wage, is nowhere being achieved,? a presentation by the government admits.

The NREGA was launched promising some million households in India a level of financial protection through guaranteed work or unemployment benefit.

According to a presentation to the National Advisory Council (NAC), the government?s guiding agency regarding policies, the main issues concerning the NREGA have been low allocation of funds, and even lower utilisation, woefully inadequate generation of employment, non-payment of minimum wages, no allowance so far, absence of facilities at worksites and doubtful productivity gains.

Another major problem faced by the government was the ground-level implementation. In most of the districts, when the programme has been implemented complains have been frequent about non-payment of the minimum wages.

The programme, announced by the government in 2005 and started implementation in 2006-07, has seen the exchequer spending Rs 8,823.36 crore in 2006-07 and a projected spending of Rs 3,487.96 crore in 2007-08.

The government?s estimates show that about 65% of the total spent went towards providing wages to local workers and the remaining to procure materials for various works.

There is a positive side to it too. According to estimates, local employment has resulted in cutting down migration of labour by as much as 60% in certain areas.