The Rs 60,000 cr loan waiver package presented by the Union finance minister P Chidambaram is now engaging the attention of the banking sector, economists and policymakers alike.

Some sections have put forward the argument that the relief package may not really bring too much cheer to some segments of debt-trapped farmers, particularly poor farmers in the dryland areas and those in the remote hilly regions of the country.

Several experts have said that the finance minister?s move has been made keeping an eye on the elections, a fact which both the government and sections of observers have also rubbished. Some have, however welcomed it saying ?it is just a beginning of recognizing farmers? problems? and the move has initiated a debate on the issue. Chidambaram has already said that he would not overburden the banks by this measure, and help would come from government sources.

But the public sector bankers appear to be a happy lot. The bankers have welcomed the finance minister’s decision. The chairman of Punjab National Bank, KC Chakravarty, told FE : ?The government has taken up the responsibility of clearing some outstanding loans of farmers. This will help the banks to reduce their NPAs and extend fresh credit. It is also good for the farmers and agriculture.”

As per general definition, a marginal farmer is one who has holding up to one hectare (2.47 acre) and the small farmer is one who has holding up to two hectare (5.94 acre). According to the recent edition of Union agriculture ministry?s Agricultural Statistics at a Glance, resource poor farmers in dryland areas of Rajasthan have holding ranging between 54 acre to 175 acre. These lands do not have any assured irrigation and are entirely dependant on erratic monsoon rains. Similar are the cases in other parts of the dryland regions in different states like in Tamil Nadu where the holding is up to 60 acre, in Haryana, Madhya Pradesh and Maharashtra up to 54 acre, in Sikkim up to 50 acre, in Uttar Pradesh up to 45 acre, in Andhra Pradesh between 35 to 54 acre, in Bihar up to 30 to 45 acre, in Gujarat between 20 to 54 acre, in Haryana up to 54 acre, in Himachal between 30 to 75 acre, in Orissa between 30 to 45 acre.

Official figures say that only about 40% of the crop area in the country is covered under assured irrigation ? some of these grow two crops and in other places one crop a year is grown.

According to the 2001 Census data, 742.6 million people or 72.2% of the country?s population live in rural areas and are directly or indirectly dependant on agriculture. The average annual exponential growth rate of the population is estimated at 1.95%. Out of the total population of 742.6 million people, Chidambaram has identified 40 million people as beneficiaries under the Rs 60,000 crore loan waiver package. All agriculture loans of 30 million small and marginal farmers that were disbursed by banks till March 31, 2007 and were overdue on December 31, 2007 and remained unpaid till February 29, 2008 would be waived off. According to government’s estimate, these unpaid loans would aggregate to Rs 50,000 crore. For another 10 million farmers, the government has decided to offer a one time settlement package for clearance of their outstanding loans relating to these dates. The package would offer a 25% rebate to farmers for payment of the balance 75%.

Farmers, whose loans were restructured and rescheduled in 2004 and 2006, will also be eligible for benefits of a waiver or one time settlement package. The package implementation is expected to be completed by June 30, this year. But in the meantime, the farmer who gets the assurance for waiving of his loans or who enter into a one-time settlement of loans can avail fresh loans from banks. .

The director of the National Centre for Agricultural Economics and Policy Research, PK Joshi, has termed the finance minister?s offer as ?mirage bonanza for agriculture?. He said: ?The argument in favor of such a provision was that the majority of farmers, who committed suicide, could not repay their loans. This bonanza will undoubtedly give some relief to roughly 35% of small and marginal farmers and nearly 50% of large farmers; largely confined in favorable environment. Those who are located in underprivileged and marginal areas (especially rainfed and backward) are often deprived of credit from the formal banking sector, such as commercial banks, cooperatives and regional rural banks, will not gain from it.

Such farmers largely rely on village moneylenders, traders and input dealers. On the other side, the honest farmers who repaid loans even at the cost of their many pressing needs may also be disappointed. Economists argue that such a policy may also induce indiscipline in the financial sector. Undoubtedly, farmers need a relief package to augment their income and empower them to repay their credit, but the mode could have been different, it is argued. Instead of this scheme, the defaulters could have been made eligible for another loan with a condition that the previous loan would be waived-off if three installments of the present loan are repaid in time. This, they say, could have prevented a recurrence of the problem.

According to Joshi, the loan waving is a temporary relief to the farmers and may not stimulate investment and trigger growth. Instead, the government should have taken steps to ensure that such a situation does not arise in future, he says. For that, the foremost requirement is to strengthen agricultural insurance sector and widen its scope with large coverage. At present it is in infancy stage, and less than 10% farmers are covered under present schemes.

To mitigate production risk, all bank loans and crop failure can be insured. This requires development of agri-insurance products, meteorological laboratories in a cluster of 4-5 villages and institutional arrangements for their effective governance. Until agricultural insurance is effectively operationalized, a fund could have been constituted to compensate farmers adversely affected as a result of droughts and floods.

The Rangaranjan Committee has also noted that only 27% farmers in the country are covered under institution credit system and many farmers source credit from local money lenders.

The president of Bharatiya Krishak Samaj, Krishan Bir Chaudhary, says: ?We welcome the finance minister?s proposal for waiving off farmers? loans. But more steps should be taken to alleviate the sufferings of farmers in dryland and hilly areas, who are not adequately covered under the package. Efforts should also be made to waive off loans of highly indebted farmers who have taken loans from the informal sector.?

Arun Kumar, an economist from the Jawharlal Nehru University, says: ?The biggest concession and the maximum publicity has gone to the debt waiver and relief scheme for the farmers. It is no doubt true that in semi arid and arid areas the definition of small and marginal farmer ought to be different from that in the irrigated areas. Further, it is also true that loans from private parties which form a major component of the problem is not being tackled. In spite of these two factors, if the amount of relief announced reaches the farmers, it will make a positive impact on their lives.?

He says ?the Budget has not spelt out where from the Rs 60,000 crore would be mobilized for waiving off farmers? loans. It has also not said whether the measure would worsen the fiscal and possibly the revenue deficits. Once the government makes it clear how the relief would be funded, many old questions will be answered. But no doubt, new ones will also crop up.