A recent Reddit post has caught attention after an Indian professional shared his F-1 visa rejection experience for an MBA program in the United States. The applicant, who worked at Amazon as a Senior Investigation & Risk Specialist for over four years, had applied for an MBA in Global Management at City University of Seattle.
Visa Interview Lasted Just Minutes
According to his post, the interview process was surprisingly short, lasting only 2–3 minutes. The officer asked about his work experience and choice of program before concluding the interaction. Despite the applicant’s preparation, which included detailed course knowledge and career plans, the officer handed him a rejection slip, stating: “You’re already successful.”
The applicant interpreted the remark as a sign that his professional achievements may have worked against him. From his perspective, the officer believed his established career did not justify leaving it for full-time study. The user admitted that his answers may not have clearly shown how the MBA was essential for advancing his career back in India.
Learning from the Rejection
In the post, the applicant highlighted key takeaways for others in similar situations. The user noted that professionals with strong careers must show that their current success is only a stepping stone, and the degree is critical for achieving specific goals.
The apllicant shared his plan for reapplying, saying he would focus on explaining why this is the right time for the MBA, showcasing unique skills the program offers, and emphasizing his intent to return to India for senior leadership roles. The professional also invited suggestions from others who faced the “already successful” objection.
One Reddit user said, “The struggles of being brown. He’s afraid you’re going to get a high paying job in the US. It would’ve been fine if you were Canadian.”
Another said, “You are Indian citizen and that is the problem.”
(This story is based on a post shared by a social media user. The details, opinions, and statements quoted herein belong solely to the original poster and do not reflect the views of Financialexpress.com. We have not independently verified the claims.)