The United States and Russia locked horns over Ukraine and other security issues on Monday with no sign of progress from either side at highly anticipated strategic talks. Low expectations from both Washington and Moscow about the high-stakes session in Geneva appeared to have been met as senior diplomats from the two countries emerged without offering any hint of success.
Neither side characterised the meeting as a complete failure, but neither did they offer any prospect of easing the increasingly worrisome standoff over Russia’s military buildup on its border with Ukraine that the West sees as a fundamental threat to European security.Nor was there any indication of movement on other, perhaps less-explosive matters that have vexed the US-Russia relationship.
Moscow insists on guarantees to halt NATO’s eastward expansion and even roll back the military alliance’s deployments in Eastern Europe, while Washington firmly rejects the demands as a nonstarter.With both sides dug in on their positions and Ukraine’s future hanging in the balance, Russian Deputy Foreign Minister Sergei Ryabkov said “no progress” was made on the central demand on NATO expansion, although he insisted: “We have no intention to invade Ukraine.” US officials openly questioned that comment.
Ryabkov spoke following talks with his US counterpart, Wendy Sherman — part of a flurry of diplomatic activity in Europe this week aimed at defusing the tensions.Sherman called the talks a “frank and forthright discussion” but would not, or could not, point to any progress.“It was not what you would call a negotiation,” she told reporters.
“We’re not to a point where we’re ready to set down texts and begin to go back and forth.” “We were firm, however, on pushing back on security proposals that are simply nonstarters for the United States,” Sherman said, adding “we will not allow anyone” to shut NATO’s “open-door policy” that extends to countries seeking to join the alliance. She said Washington “will not forgo bilateral cooperation with sovereign states that wish to work with the United States.And, we will not make decisions about Ukraine without Ukraine, about Europe without Europe or about NATO without NATO.” Russian President Vladimir Putin has described NATO expansion to Ukraine and other former Soviet states as a “red line” for Moscow, demanding binding guarantees from the West that they wouldn’t become members of the alliance.
Moscow has sought to wrest a string of concessions from the US and its Western allies, and has massed an estimated 1,00,000 troops near Ukraine in steps that have raised concerns about a possible military intervention there.“The situation now is so dangerous, and so — I would say — precarious that we cannot afford any further delays in resolution of this very fundamental question,” Ryabkov said at a separate news conference at the Russian mission.
“As President Putin said, on many occasions, we cannot backpedal. We cannot go backwards. There is no further space for us to do so.” Ryabkov rattled off Russian concerns and demands issued last month on subjects like NATO expansion and wanting Western commitments not to deploy offensive weapons near Russian borders.
“The American side has treated the Russian proposals seriously and deeply studied them,” he said, adding that he characterised Moscow’s demand for legally binding guarantees that NATO would not move eastward as “an absolute imperative for us.” Ryabkov emphasised that it would be hard to work on other issues if the US stonewalled on Russia’s key demands.
“If now NATO proceeds towards deployment of capabilities that are being developed very rapidly in the US, and will possibly be introduced somewhere in Europe, it would require a military response on the Russian part, that is a decision to counter this threat through means at our discretion,” said Ryabkov, speaking in English. “That will inevitably, unavoidably damage security of the U.S. and its European allies.” He did not elaborate.After Ryabkov stated that Russia had no intention to invade Ukraine, the US Ambassador to the United Nations, Linda Thomas-Greenfield, was publicly skeptical.
“I wish to believe him, I wish that it is true that they have no plans, but everything we’ve seen so far indicate that they are making motions in that direction,” she told reporters at the UN headquarters in New York.Echoing comments from US Secretary of State Antony Blinken, Sherman said progress could only happen if Russia “stays at the table and takes concrete steps to de-escalate tensions.” De-escalation, she said, would include returning the Russian troops now deployed on Ukraine’s borders to their barracks.
“We’ve made it clear that if Russia further invades Ukraine there will be significant costs and consequences well beyond what they faced in 2014,” she said. “Russia has a stark choice to make.” However, neither Sherman nor State Department spokesman Ned Price would say if the US would move ahead with sanctions if Russia opts not to invade but also refuses to withdraw its troops from the border.Monday’s meeting was part of “Strategic Security Dialogue” talks on arms control and other broad issues launched by Putin and US President Joe Biden at a June summit in the Swiss city.Talks between Russia and NATO are planned on Wednesday in Brussels followed by a meeting in Vienna of the Organization for Security and Cooperation in Europe on Thursday.