Seven major oil-producing countries have decided to keep their oil output unchanged in November, even when crude shipments from the Middle East have recovered to almost pre-war levels. But oil prices remain high, with Brent crude still around $100 a barrel. Renewed attacks on ships near the Strait of Hormuz and the rising cost of moving oil out of the Gulf are keeping pressure on the global energy market.
For markets, the bigger question now is not just how much oil is leaving the Gulf, but whether the recovery can continue. The attacks are keeping shipping and insurance costs high, which is stopping the market from fully returning to normal. Shipbrokers say the shuttle runs used to move crude out of the Gulf alone add $15 to $20 a barrel, and that is before insurance is counted.
Amid this, OPEC+ made up of Saudi Arabia, Russia, Iraq, Kuwait, Kazakhstan, Algeria and Oman, agreed on Sunday to maintain the production levels set for September, according to the Organisation of the Petroleum Exporting Countries (OPEC).
Saudi Arabia, Russia and Iraq will remain the biggest producers under the arrangement, followed by Kuwait, Kazakhstan, Algeria and Oman. The seven countries will meet again on November 1 to review the situation in the oil market.
Gulf oil flows near pre-war levels, Iran war keeps pressure on markets
The decision comes more than seven months after the war began on February 28, when the United States and Israel launched attacks on Iran.
Benchmark Brent crude has been trading around or above $100 a barrel. Other market data showed Brent and the US benchmark West Texas Intermediate both closing above $90 a barrel on Friday.
Yet physical supplies from the Gulf have largely bounced back. JPMorgan said this past week that Middle East crude exports reached about 17.5 million barrels per day, or roughly 98% of pre-war levels. Goldman Sachs put Persian Gulf exports even higher, at about 19 million barrels per day. Kpler also said Gulf crude exports have recovered to pre-war levels, though it put the September figure at a minimum of 16.5 million barrels per day.
Kpler said the rebound has come through a reshaped export system. About 40% of Gulf crude now leaves without crossing Hormuz, up from 17% before the war, as Saudi Arabia and the UAE make greater use of pipelines. Of the crude that did cross Hormuz in August, more than 70% was transferred to other tankers offshore. The recovery has also come even when a US naval blockade keeps Iran’s own oil exports at close to zero.
What’s the big worry?
If the barrels are flowing, why are prices still high? Because the recovery is costly and fragile. The UK Maritime Trade Operations has reported seven strikes on vessels around the strait since September 28, all near its narrowest point. Iran’s Revolutionary Guard navy warned ships on Saturday that those using the US-backed southern route would be targeted. A US official told the Wall Street Journal that Iran’s ability to hit ships has improved in recent weeks.
There are already some early signs that the latest attacks are affecting oil shipments. Rory Johnston, founder of oil research firm Commodity Context, estimates that flows have fallen by around 2 million to 3 million barrels a day. He cautioned that the figure could change as more data comes in. Getting a clear picture is difficult because many ships have switched off their transponders to avoid being tracked and targeted.
The bigger problem is the rising cost of moving the oil. Gulf producers are spending $30 million to $40 million on each round trip through the Strait of Hormuz. Under the system, tankers load oil inside the Gulf, pass through the Strait and then transfer the crude to ships waiting offshore.
Shipbrokers cited by The Wall Street Journal estimate that the cost comes to around $15 to $20 a barrel, even before insurance is added.
HSBC analyst Kim Fustier said Middle East oil exports are rising “at enormous cost”. He also warned that the expensive shuttle runs and military-protected convoys may not be sustainable for long. Brent crude settled at $102.25 a barrel on Friday, up nearly 5% for the week.
The bigger concern for the oil market is what happens if Iran starts targeting energy infrastructure.
Esfandyar Batmanghelidj, founder and CEO of the Bourse & Bazaar Foundation think tank, told Fortune that Iran still has the ability to hit drilling and refining facilities. He said Tehran could escalate further if President Donald Trump does not feel enough pressure to consider the diplomatic options available.
Iran has not yet launched what Batmanghelidj called a “scorched earth campaign”, but he warned that it could happen if the conflict continues.
There is little sign of a diplomatic breakthrough either. Trump has rejected Tehran’s offer of a seven-day ceasefire that would fully reopen the Strait of Hormuz. In return, Iran wanted the US to lift its blockade and unfreeze Iranian assets.
Sources told The Wall Street Journal that Trump expects the US to resume bombing Iran after the US midterm elections. With more attacks on ships and the possibility of strikes on energy facilities, the recovery in Middle East oil shipments remains vulnerable.
G7 plans emergency oil release
The Group of Seven wealthy democracies is also preparing to use emergency oil stocks to ease pressure on the market.
On Friday, the G7 announced plans to release 100 million barrels of oil and fuel products from emergency reserves in the coming weeks. The release will start with “substantial” amounts of diesel. Diesel prices have recently reached record highs in several markets.
The G7 said it would make a “frontloaded substantial release” of diesel within the next 20 days. The rest of the emergency supply will be released over the following four months.
The impact is already being felt in the United States.
According to AAA, regular gasoline was averaging about $4.37 a gallon on Sunday. Diesel was around $6.34 a gallon, compared with about $3.70 a year earlier.
The sharp rise has put pressure on farmers during the harvest season and on truckers who depend heavily on diesel. Higher diesel costs also affect the cost of moving food and other everyday goods across the country.
With the US midterm elections approaching, fuel prices have also become a political issue in Washington. Republicans and Democrats have been blaming each other over the rise in prices as well as the handling of the war.
Asian countries are watching closely
Asian countries are among the most exposed to any disruption in the Gulf because Asia is the main destination for crude oil and gas shipped through the Strait of Hormuz.
India imports most of the oil it uses, with a significant amount of its crude as well as LPG and LNG coming from the Gulf region or passing through Hormuz. A prolonged period of high oil prices can therefore increase India’s import bill and put pressure on the current account deficit and the rupee.
Higher petrol and diesel prices can push up transport and food costs. Higher LPG prices can put additional pressure on households, while more expensive oil and gas can raise the cost of fertiliser and petrochemical products.
India has also increased its use of discounted Russian crude in recent years. Decisions by OPEC+ members such as Russia and Saudi Arabia can therefore influence how much oil is available and at what price. India’s strategic petroleum reserves are relatively small compared with the country’s overall oil consumption. This means that emergency releases by major economies can still be important for global prices and supply conditions.
China, the world’s biggest crude oil importer, is also likely to face higher costs for its factories and refineries if oil prices stay high. However, China has large stockpiles and has diversified its sources of oil.
Japan and South Korea depend almost entirely on imported energy. A large share of their supplies comes from the Middle East, making them particularly vulnerable to any disruption around the Strait of Hormuz.
Both countries could turn to strategic reserves and work with G7 countries if the situation worsens.
Pakistan, Bangladesh and Sri Lanka are more vulnerable because their foreign-exchange reserves are relatively limited. A prolonged rise in energy prices could lead to fuel shortages or rationing, power cuts and higher inflation. It could also put more pressure on their IMF-backed economic programmes.
Keeping production unchanged also gives the countries room to change course at the next OPEC meeting on November 1. That decision will depend on how the war develops, how much oil is reaching global markets and whether emergency stock releases are helping to control prices.
For now, the decision does not bring a major increase in supply or create another immediate shock to the market.
