A controversial moment on Day 2 of the Tata Steel Chess India Rapid in Kolkata became the talking point of the tournament, sparking widespread debate within the chess community. The flashpoint came in Round 6 when R Praggnanandhaa, with just one second left on the clock, halted play during a critical promotion sequence in his game against Wesley So.
With one second left, what triggered Praggnanandhaa to stop the clock?
Praggnanandhaa had pushed a pawn to the final rank but ran out of time before completing the promotion by replacing it with a queen. As his clock was about to expire, he stopped the timer and appealed for assistance, triggering confusion over the correct application of the rules. While commentators initially felt the game would be decided on time in So’s favour, the arbiters ruled the contest a draw after deliberation.
Sharp criticism from Chris Bird
The decision drew sharp criticism from experienced arbiter Chris Bird, who questioned the interpretation of the Laws of Chess. Citing Article 6.11.2, Bird argued that stopping the clock is permitted only after a promotion has taken place and the required piece is unavailable, a condition he maintained was not met in this case.
Anand, Nihal shine as tournament gathers pace
Beyond the controversy, the event continued to showcase high-quality rapid chess. Five-time world champion Viswanathan Anand demonstrated his trademark resilience to recover from an early setback. In Round 4, Anand appeared in control before a costly rook blunder allowed Arjun Erigaisi to snatch victory.
The veteran responded in style, however, defeating Hans Niemann and Volodar Murzin to climb into a share of the lead with Nihal Sarin on 4.5 points after six rounds. Nihal, meanwhile, enjoyed a strong run of form, capitalising on errors by Niemann and Murzin before producing a polished endgame performance to overcome Vidit Gujrathi.
In the women’s section, Kateryna Lagno emerged as the sole leader with 4.5 points. Among the Indian contingent, Vantika Agrawal was placed fifth on three points, while Harika Dronavalli, R Vaishali and Rakshitta Ravi remained firmly in the hunt.