Vexing Law

By: |
Published: July 23, 2015 12:35:31 AM

MP’s solution to vexatious litigation seems worse than the problem itself.

While insufficient bench strength means that there are not enough judges to hear cases, frivolous litigation is also a factor behind the jam in India’s courts—which explains why the Madhya Pradesh (MP) government would bring a Vexatious Legislation (Prevention) Bill. As per the proposed law, the state’s advocate general may file an application in the High Court to declare a person “a vexatious litigant” and stop him from initiating any civil or criminal proceedings without prior permission of the court. If a person is declared a vexatious litigant, it would also mean that all cases filed by him have to be withdrawn. And once one is declared a vexatious litigant, that tag would stick—the litigant may only get relief from the Supreme Court.

But MP’s solution seems worse than the problem. There is a strong chance of it being misused, for instance, in a situation where the powers that be find themselves in the dock. Besides, the fallout could be akin to the story of the boy who cried wolf. Once a litigant is declared vexatious, he would have to start with a pre-trial hearing, where he has to convince the court that his matter merits the court’s attention and time. Also, the government could find itself on the wrong side of such a law—the tax department, given its litigation history, could be a likely candidate. While the Law Commission, in a 2005 report on curbing vexatious litigation, proposed a similar penalty for such litigants, it would be wiser to go with the solution proposed by the Supreme Court—the apex court, in 2011, had suggested hiking the penalty by a whopping 3,000%, to R1 lakh. While it may not be a deterrent for litigants with deep pockets, those who incessantly file purported public interest litigations, in which the “public interest” bit seems frequently missing, would think twice.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.