Rajya Sabha right in demanding a rework of the Surrogacy Bill

By: |
Published: November 27, 2019 12:37 AM

Members have raised serious objections against the Bill, passed by Lok Sabha in the monsoon session.

parliament, rajya sabhaMembers of the Upper House believe that some of the provisions, like surrogacy only by a close relative, the five-year waiting period, and a rule limiting it to only married couples, were prohibitive and exclusionary.

The prime minister, while addressing the 250th session of Rajya Sabha, remarked that the House has ensured checks and balances for the system, which are essential for a democracy. Although he did go on to say that there is also a difference between checking and clogging, the decision of the Upper House to send the Surrogacy Bill that the government is pushing to a select Rajya Sabha panel is a sound one. Members have raised serious objections against the Bill, passed by Lok Sabha in the monsoon session. Across party lines, members of the Upper House believe that some of the provisions, like surrogacy only by a close relative, the five-year waiting period, and a rule limiting it to only married couples, were prohibitive and exclusionary. They were quick to point out that, in its present form, the Bill would lead to exploitation of close relatives, as also the surrogate parents, who would needlessly have to wait five years.

While there is no doubt that, sans regulations, surrogacy sweatshops had mushroomed across the country—the health minister, in a recent debate, highlighted that there were 3,000 such clinics in India—the government’s bill only makes matters worse. Restrictions will mean clandestine sweatshops thrive. With such onerous regulations, people could also go to nations where laws are more liberal. A better solution would be to allow commercial surrogacy while strictly enforcing provisions that safeguard the surrogate’s health and commercial interests. Once sweatshops are history, the National Surrogacy Board can regulate the industry, as happened in the case of adoption.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1PM Modi can learn from Jawaharlal Nehru what not to do, writes Meghnad Desai
2China broke decades-long peace under PM Modi’s watch, writes P Chidambaram
3Golfers are ‘luckier than most’, but we can still get out and play. Here’s a checklist of factors