Sukanya Samriddhi vs Bank FD vs RD vs PPF vs MF vs insurance: Suitability and pros & cons

By: |
November 24, 2018 2:40 PM

As the rate of inflation in education is more than the rate general inflation, you need to chalk out a financial plan to meet the expenses.

financial planning for children, Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana, Bank FD, fixed deposits, recurring deposits, RD, Public Provident Fund, PPF, mutual funds, MF, insurance plan, child insurance plans, child education, marriageThere are also some exclusive financial products available for girl child that the government launched as a part of its ‘Beti Bachao Beti Padhao’ campaign.

From study to choosing a desirable career to marriage, upbringing a child is a huge task, which, apart from care, also needs money. As the rate of inflation in education is more than the rate general inflation, you need to chalk out a financial plan to meet the expenses. There are many financial products available, which you may use judiciously to meet your financial targets. There are also some exclusive financial products available for girl child that the government launched as a part of its ‘Beti Bachao Beti Padhao’ campaign.

Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana

Small deposit scheme Sukanya Samriddhi Yojana (SSY) is aimed at meeting the expenses of higher education and marriage of your daughter. The parents or legal guardians of a girl child may open an account till 10 years of the age of the girl. The account may be closed after 21 years. However, normal premature closure is allowed after completion of 18 years, provided that girl gets married.

Currently, the maximum amount may be invested in an SSY in a financial year is Rs 1,50,000. The amount invested is eligible for tax deductions u/s 80C as well as the interests earned and the maturity amounts are also tax free.

The government declares the rate of interest for SSY accounts on quarterly basis and generally keeps it higher than other small savings schemes like NSC, KVP, PPF etc. At present, the rate is 8.5 per cent, which if continues to remain same, would generate a corpus of Rs 74,96,802 at the end of 21 years, if Rs 1,50,000 is invested at the beginning of every year for 15 years.

Sukanya Samridhhi Yojona is a very suitable product for girl child, as it is tailor made for them. It also provides handsome rate of return and overall tax benefits. However, the long tenure and restrictions on withdrawals make it an illiquid investment.

Bank Fixed Deposits

For investing in fixed deposits (FDs) you need to have lump sum money in your hand. FDs are one of the most popular choices in India. Most people invest in FDs because they are easy to get from the banks that have created immense trust in the mind of the account holders. However, FDs don’t provide protection against inflation and the interest earned are also taxable.

With highest interest rates on FDs varying between 6 and 7 per cent apart from tax and inflation inefficiency, FDs may not create enough wealth that is needed for your daughter’s higher education and marriage purpose. So, you may use FDs only to park small amount of excess money to meet the associated expenses.

Recurring Deposits

Although, recurring deposits (RDs) are a modified version of FDs, where you may invest periodically on small amount instead of lump sum one, but it is a better option to park the small amount of money that you may save every month. As it may not be convenient for you to save large amount in FD regularly, the small amounts in vested in RD may come handy when you need some lump sum money for expenditure. However, like FDs, RDs are also tax and inflation inefficient.

Public Provident Fund (PPF)

It is a good idea to open a PPF account in the name of your girl child and divide the money you want to invest in it between your and your daughter’s account (maximum Rs 1,50,000 may be invested by a PAN card holder, be it in one account or more accounts). However, it would be even better if you open an SSY account for your daughter instead of bifurcating your investment for retirement. Otherwise, with tax deductions on investment and tax-free interest and maturity, along with pretty good interest rate, PPF is a good vehicle for accumulating a corpus.

Mutual Fund (MF)

As the goal of higher education and marriage of your daughter are a long-term goal, you may start SIPs in equity mutual funds safely to get a return that beats the inflation. But you should not get panicked by daily turmoil in markets, which affect the NAVs of mutual funds in short term. Start monitoring the NAVs of the funds a year before your daughter is about to get admission for higher education or about to get married, so that you may redeem you funds at good value. There are also some child specific funds available with longer lock-in period and higher exit loads if redeemed before the duration for which the fund is taken to discourage early withdrawal of money for any other purpose than meeting the needs of the child.


There are many child insurance products available in the market in the form of money back plans or regular plans. One of the important feature of child insurance is the premium waiver benefit (PWB), which allows the insurance to continue even without paying premium in case of untimely demise of the earning member, who used to pay the premium. However, there is no point in taking insurance on child’s life, as it is not the motive of child insurance to get lump sum money in case of death of the insured child. So, it’s better to take insurance on your life, making daughter the nominee.

So, along with other investments, better to take a term insurance plan. Otherwise, even a unit-linked insurance plan (ULIP) would be a good option. There are, however, options available to take PWB in some endowment plans even on your life, which also provide additional risk covers like instant payout of sum assured (SA) along with yearly payout of certain percentage of SA apart from the maturity benefits, if taken judiciously with term rider, accidental rider, PWB etc. For example, in case of a 20-year policy of Rs 10 lakh SA, taken with all the riders, if the insured person dies due to accident in the very first year, total payout would be as much as 6 times the SA, that is Rs 60 lakh. Such plans may prove even better than term plans because the nominee would get immediate lump sum payment to clear debts, if any, and to make some investments, then regular yearly payments to bear child’s expenses and finally, lump sum payment again on maturity to meet expenses for higher education and marriage. In case the life insured survives the full policy term, he or she will get lump sum maturity benefit, which, along with bonus, would be around twice the SA, that is around Rs 20 lakh. But such plans are expensive due to high risk cover.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, Check out latest IPO News, Best Performing IPOs, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1Tips to make the best use of credit cards
2Your Money: Steps to build a stable retirement income
3How to prepay a Rs 40 lakh home loan of 15 years in 7 years and save in lakhs?