Sell Bata India as under- investment to impact earnings: Ambit Capital

By: | Updated: December 10, 2015 7:00 AM

Bata India, India’s largest footwear retailer, will face an existential crisis, as it cedes distribution equity to e-commerce...

BSE Sensex, NSE Nifty, MMTCBata India, India’s largest footwear retailer, will face an existential crisis, as it cedes distribution equity to e-commerce (footwear market size of 0mn). (Express Photo)

Bata India, India’s largest footwear retailer, will face an existential crisis, as it cedes distribution equity to e-commerce (footwear market size of $500mn). The under-investment in the brand (meager 1% of revenues over CY08-15) will bite into future earnings whereas the over-investment in stores will cap capital efficiency. FY17E EBITDA margin of 12.4% remains a far cry away from its historical peak (15.6% in CY13) given high fixed costs (35% of FY15 sales) amid pressure to increase commissions and ad-spend. A significant turnaround is some time away given (a) historical high inventory (nine months) requiring write-downs; (b) high possibility for gross margin compression and (c) declining asset turns (2.4x in FY17 from 3.1x in CY09); we expect FY17E RoE to be 19%.
We re-initiate with Sell and implied valuation of 23.5x FY17E EPS.

Over CY09-FY15, Bata generated Rs 12 bn CFO; rather than investing in the brand, it expanded retail space to 3.3mn sq ft (from 1.3mn), investing 1/4th CFO in brandex vs equal outlay by peers. Unparalleled network (>500 cities) and 84-year-old history made it a default consumer choice until customer moved online and started buying more aspirational brands, easily available online than Bata.

Bata brand’s diminishing distribution equity is evident from the muted growth (10%/4% in CY13/FY15) despite adding 50% more space.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Switch to Hindi Edition