Sell Bata India as under- investment to impact earnings: Ambit Capital

By: |
Updated: Dec 10, 2015 7:00 AM

Bata India, India’s largest footwear retailer, will face an existential crisis, as it cedes distribution equity to e-commerce...

BSE Sensex, NSE Nifty, MMTCBata India, India’s largest footwear retailer, will face an existential crisis, as it cedes distribution equity to e-commerce (footwear market size of $500mn). (Express Photo)

Bata India, India’s largest footwear retailer, will face an existential crisis, as it cedes distribution equity to e-commerce (footwear market size of $500mn). The under-investment in the brand (meager 1% of revenues over CY08-15) will bite into future earnings whereas the over-investment in stores will cap capital efficiency. FY17E EBITDA margin of 12.4% remains a far cry away from its historical peak (15.6% in CY13) given high fixed costs (35% of FY15 sales) amid pressure to increase commissions and ad-spend. A significant turnaround is some time away given (a) historical high inventory (nine months) requiring write-downs; (b) high possibility for gross margin compression and (c) declining asset turns (2.4x in FY17 from 3.1x in CY09); we expect FY17E RoE to be 19%.
We re-initiate with Sell and implied valuation of 23.5x FY17E EPS.

Over CY09-FY15, Bata generated Rs 12 bn CFO; rather than investing in the brand, it expanded retail space to 3.3mn sq ft (from 1.3mn), investing 1/4th CFO in brandex vs equal outlay by peers. Unparalleled network (>500 cities) and 84-year-old history made it a default consumer choice until customer moved online and started buying more aspirational brands, easily available online than Bata.

Bata brand’s diminishing distribution equity is evident from the muted growth (10%/4% in CY13/FY15) despite adding 50% more space.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1Colgate Palmolive shares buy or sell? Falls 3% in two days, analysts see upside as margins improve
2Charts show these 4 realty stocks may rally 17% in 3 weeks; realty index beats Nifty 50 in Oct so far
3UltraTech Cement shares open strong as Q2 net profit doubles, but fail to hold gains; should you buy?