Maintain ‘hold’ with TP of Rs 197 for Power Grid Corp

By: | Published: September 11, 2018 6:11 AM

Key takeaways from our recent meeting with PGCIL’s management: (1) Order book could double — visibility can improve substantially if PGCIL receives Rs 500-600 bn projects on nomination basis (cost-plus) to link 7-8 GW of wind projects in Gujarat and Tamil Nadu.

Power Grid Corp, PGCIL, CERC, HVDC projects, RoE, CAGRHistorically, PGCIL’s core RoE declined from 18-19% over 2009-14 to 15-16% over FY15-18 despite CERC maintaining the base RoE (refer exhibit 7).

Key takeaways from our recent meeting with PGCIL’s management: (1) Order book could double — visibility can improve substantially if PGCIL receives Rs 500-600 bn projects on nomination basis (cost-plus) to link 7-8 GW of wind projects in Gujarat and Tamil Nadu. This will clear overhang of low visibility; (2) Core RoE of 15% in FY18 appears suppressed (vs. 16.3% normalised) due to wage provisions (one-off) and under-recoveries in O&M; (3) Expects CERC to maintain base RoE at 15.5% in upcoming tariff policy given the need for transmission to keep pace with robust renewable capacity addition; we expect CERC to reduce base RoE to 14% due to PGCIL’s strong free cash which suffices to meet growth; and (4) FY19/FY20 capitalisation at Rs -270 bn; however, FY20 capitalisation includes a single large HVDC project Rs 200 bn, which if delayed will slip to FY21.

PGCIL’s era of high earnings growth (FY08-FY13:19% CAGR; FY13-FY18:16% CAGR) is over and we expect considerably lower earnings CAGR of 7% over FY18-20 due to (1) flat capitalisation of Rs 250 bn p.a. And (2) assumption of lower base RoE of 14% from FY20 vs. 15.5% currently. We believe even if capitalisation in FY20 turns to be lower at Rs 100-150 bn vs. management’s guidance of Rs 250 bn due to deferral of commissioning of HVDC projects by a couple of quarters, it would not impact the earnings trajectory considering its benefits would have reflected only from FY21. Also, the award of Rs 500-600 bn of projects on a nomination basis would extend the growth horizon beyond FY21 by a couple of years, but not materially alter the earnings growth trajectory.

We believe the key overhang is the upcoming CERC’s tariff policy for 2019-22. Historically, PGCIL’s core RoE declined from 18-19% over 2009-14 to 15-16% over FY15-18 despite CERC maintaining the base RoE (refer exhibit 7). At CMP, PGCIL’s stock valuation appears cheap at 11x FY19/FY20E P/E despite superior business model of take-or-pay and on cost plus, but is justified due to slower earnings growth and regulatory uncertainties. Maintain HOLD with TP of Rs 197.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Switch to Hindi Edition