Little reprieve from stress

By: |
Published: November 3, 2014 5:31:36 AM

Q2FY15 earnings came in at R5.8 bn, up 14% year-on-year but 43% below our estimate on higher than expected provisions and decline in margins.

Punjab National Bank
Rating: Neutral (V)

Q2FY15 earnings came in at R5.8 bn, up 14% year-on-year but 43% below our estimate on higher than expected provisions and decline in margins. The y-o-y increase despite the spike in provisions was on the back of a lower base in Q2FY14.

Operating highlights: Q2FY15 NII (net interest income) was up only 3% y-o-y despite 14% y-o-y loan growth leading to NIM (net interest margin) declining 24 basis points to 3.18%. This was due to the increased share of lower yielding overseas loans (57% y-o-y) in the loan mix, and interest income reversals of R2.9 bn from higher loan restructuring and R1 bn from fresh slippages. However, the management sees it stabilising at 3.4-3.5% levels by end-FY15e.

Click here for graph

Total deposits were up 17% y-o-y although domestic deposits grew by only 4% y-o-y versus system deposit growth of 13% y-o-y. Employee expenses were up 23% y-o-y driven by higher wage hike provisions (R2.4 bn versus a run-rate of R1.8 bn), and pension expenses (R2.7 bn) related to change in actuarial assumptions. Asset quality worsened as GNPL (gross non-performing loans) ratio increased by 17 bps quarter-on-quarter to 5.7% as slippages climbed 70 bps to 4% leading to 33 bps increase in credit cost to 1.9%.

Of R16.4 bn provisioned for loan losses, R6.8 bn of specific provisions were made by the bank in excess of prudential requirements in order to maintain coverage at 59%, versus 60% in Q1. Fresh restructuring was at R33 bn and restructured book is now at 10%. Tax rate was higher at 48% mainly due to higher taxes related to depreciation write-back. Tier-1 ratio stood at 8.7%.

Outlook: While economic recovery could pick up gradually, PNB could see stress continuing for the next couple of quarters. We lower our FY16e and FY17e earnings’ estimates by 7.1% and 6.2% on lower loan growth, margins and higher tax rate. That said, we continue to believe that it’s better positioned vs most PSU peers to take advantage of a turnaround in FY16e.

Valuation: PNB is trading at 1.0x 12-month rolled forward ABV (adjusted book value). We continue to value PNB at 1.1x P/AB (price to adjusted book), resulting in a revised TP (target price) of R1,063 (R1,088) based on a single-stage Gordon growth model (Oct 2016 base from Jul 2016 base), implying a potential return of 15.6%. Maintain Neutral (V). Upside risks: Bottoming of growth and asset quality cycle; potential resolution of power sector issues. Downside risks: Continuing asset quality and margin stress.


Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.