Coal India rating – Hold: Performance in Q1 was below expectations

By: |
August 16, 2021 6:00 AM

Staff cost is a headwind; jump in capex is dragging cash flows; outlook for firm is lacklustre; estimates fine-tuned; ‘Hold’ retained

The sharp rise in capex is also dragging cash flows. We fine-tune estimates and retain Hold.The sharp rise in capex is also dragging cash flows. We fine-tune estimates and retain Hold.

COAL’s Q1 volumes were 5% above Q1FY20 but cash Ebitda was 39% lower (39% below JEFe) led by lower realisations and higher costs. Volume growth has improved in recent months and COAL might take a price hike in FY22; however, rising staff cost due to workers’ wage revision is posing a headwind. EPS has been almost flat over FY13-20 and we see just 2% CAGR over FY21-23. The sharp rise in capex is also dragging cash flows. We fine-tune estimates and retain Hold.

Ebitda miss in Q1: COAL’s Q1 dispatch volumes were 5% above Q1FY20 but ASPs were 4% lower due to weaker e-auction realisations. Reported Ebitda was 27% below Q1FY20. Excluding the non-cash stripping-activity-adjustment expense, cash Ebitda was 39% below Q1FY20. Cash cost/t rose 14% vs Q1FY20 while cash Ebitda/t was 42% lower. FSA volumes were down 4% q-o-q while FSA ASP were flattish q-o-q. Q1 e-auction volumes grew 4% q-o-q while e-auction ASP declined 10% q-o-q. Q1 PAT was down 31% q-o-q (32% below Q1FY20).

Volumes picking up and possibility of price hike: COAL’s dispatch volumes fell 6% over FY19-21 due to weaker economy and Covid, but have started to pick up; April-July 2021 dispatches are 5% higher than 2019 (July +8%). We factor in shipments growing 12% y-o-y in FY22 on a low base, followed by 5% growth in FY23. Production also picked up in July, rising 11% above 2019. We believe a price hike for linkage coal may be on the anvil as the company usually raises prices close to wage revisions. We have assumed 5% hike in H2FY22 in our estimates.

Cost headwinds hurting margins: COAL’s wages revision has been due from June 2021. Our estimates factor in staff costs rising 24% over FY21-23. COAL’s cash Ebitda/t is down from Rs 483 in FY19-20 to Rs 349 in FY21 and we expect Rs 377-402 in FY22-23 (Q1FY22: Rs 287).

Cash flows under pressure: COAL plans to incur capex of Rs 160-170 bn in FY22-23 vs an average of Rs 73 bn over FY16-20. COAL believes current spend is better reflective of business requirements. COAL generated negative FCF in FY20-21 and we expect a subdued Rs 14-34 bn in FY22-23 versus Rs 70-125 bn in FY17-19.

Valuation too cheap for a cautious view: The stock has underperformed Nifty-50 by ~100% since Jan-2018, and its 6.7x FY23E PE is undemanding. It also offers 9% dividend yield assuming 60% payout, although this will be partly funded by cash on the B/S. The stock is unlikely to re-rate though given multiple operational challenges, deteriorated cash flow profile, large contingent liabilities and ESG concerns. We fine-tune FY22-23e EPS and retain Hold with Rs 135 PT based on 6.0x FY23e PE.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, Check out latest IPO News, Best Performing IPOs, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1Sebi board clears frameworks for gold, social stock exchanges
2Reduction in GST, subsidy on conversion kits to push Auto LPG growth
3Kanhaiya Kumar and Jignesh Mevani join Congress as party looks to infuse fresh blood