Coal India Rating: Buy; August output/offtake lowest in 3 years

By: |
Published: September 7, 2019 12:39:54 AM

Uptick is likely from Q3; while FY20 growth target is high, dividend yield and free cash flow are positives; ‘Buy’ retained

Coal India, SECL production, Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd, Bharat Coking Coal Ltd, Western Coalfields LtdAugust production/offtake disappoint CIL’s August 2019 production and offtake volume decline is the worst in the past three years. Production and offtake slid 10% y-o-y each to 34.8mt and 40.5mt, respectively.

Coal India (CIL) has reported a 10% y-o-y decline each in August production and sales volume, now down to their lowest levels in the past three years. Key highlights: (i) Larger subsidiaries MCL (Mahanadi Coalfields Ltd) and SECL (South-Eastern Coalfields Ltd) accounted for the bulk of the decline; (ii) continued low rake availability – down to 178/day in August from 205/day in July—dampened offtake; (iii) production volume was hit by fatalities at MCL and SECL and higher-than-normal rainfall. That said, we expect an uptick in production/offtake Q3 onwards as: (i) weather-related issues subside; (ii) rake availability improves; and (iii) production normalises at MCL and SECL.
Hence, we do not believe our FY20e volume growth of 4.6% is at risk, but note that CIL’s target of 8.5% is daunting. That said, a healthy dividend yield and free cash flow are positives. Maintain Buy with a TP of Rs 235 (8.6x FY21e EPS).

August production/offtake disappoint CIL’s August 2019 production and offtake volume decline is the worst in the past three years. Production and offtake slid 10% y-o-y each to 34.8mt and 40.5mt, respectively. Key highlights: (i) Production at MCL was impacted by about 3mt owing to fatalities in late July; (ii) SECL’s production was impacted by fatalities due to a mine accident on 20 August, not to mention the delay in finalisation of subcontracts; and (iii) production at WCL (Western Coalfields Ltd) dipped owing to higher-than-expected rainfall in August. On the offtake front, lower rake availability led to loading of 178 rakes/day compared with 205/day in July 2019.

Minimal risk to our production/offtake estimate

In our view, CIL is likely to turn in production/offtake growth of 4.5/4.6% in FY20 led by: (i) resolution of subcontracting issues at SECL; (ii) production normalisation at MCL; and (iii) improvement in rake availability. We see CIL’s internal target of 660mt, which implies 15% y-o-y growth for the rest of FY20 – as daunting.

Outlook and valuation: Production woes likely over; maintain ‘BUY’

We expect CIL’s production/offtake volume to show an uptick Q3FY20 onwards mainly due to a pick-up in business at MCL and SECL. While BCCL (Bharat Coking Coal Ltd) remains a concern, we do not believe our FY20e offtake of 638mt is at risk. Maintain ‘BUY/SO’ with a target price of Rs 235/share. The stock is trading at 6.8x FY21e EPS.

 

Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.