Analyst Corner| ITC: Stock under pressure on proposed tobacco tax policy

By: |
October 29, 2021 7:24 AM

ITC stock has been under pressure on reports that the gov't has formed an expert panel to develop a comprehensive tax policy on tobacco

ITC stockMother Sparsh, which was incorporated on February 5, 2016 had reported a turnover of Rs 15.44 crore in FY 2020-21. (File)

Key takeaway: ITC stock has been under pressure on reports that the gov’t has formed an expert panel to develop a comprehensive tax policy on tobacco. We take a deep-dive into WHO’s MPOWER measures, which prescribe tax at >75% of retail price. Cigarette tax in India is at c.55%, but tax on other forms (bidi, chewing) is comparatively low. We believe a serious effort to curb tobacco use requires a balanced approach; penalizing only cigarettes may otherwise be counter-productive.

MPOWER: is an acronym for a set of six measures, prescribed by WHO, to curb tobacco consumption & was introduced in 2008. The six measures are: 1) Monitoring tobacco consumption & effectiveness of preventive measures; 2) Protect people from tobacco smoke; 3) Offer help to quit tobacco; 4) Warn about the dangers; 5) Enforce bans on advertising, promotion etc; and 6) Raise taxes on tobacco.

Point system: Each country is ranked on each of these six MPOWER measures on a five-point scale, and countries are expected to reach the highest level of achievement (on this five-point scale) across each of the six measures.
Where India stands: India has the highest level of achievement in two components ‘O’ & ‘W’. The country has taken substantial initiatives even across other measures and ranks 4 out of 5 across each of them as at 2020. In case of R, which stands for raise taxes, WHO requires every country to ensure that >75% of retail price is tax.

India is currently at c.55%; there are countries on either side i.e. lower as well as higher, with some even at c.80%.
Way forward: The expert group will analyse the existing tax structure on all forms of tobacco, including smoking & smokeless. The intent is to also develop a roadmap for tax policy and recommend immediate steps to make India compliant with regard to the ‘R’ component.

Cigarette vs. tobacco: At this stage, it is near-impossible to predict what the expert group would recommend and what gov’t will implement. However, if the real objective is to curb tobacco consumption, there is a strong case to raise taxes as well as have better processes on tax collection for non-cigarettes, which form nearly 90% of consumption but contribute only 20% of taxation.

What about collection? Aggressive tax hike would weigh on volumes and in turn impact tax collection, which could be a concern for the finance ministry. We note that cigarettes contribute >30% to the Compensation Cess Fund of India and is an important resource pool for the government to settle tax deficits faced by states.

Our view on ITC: This move has clearly raised concerns on tobacco taxation in the run-up to the Budget on February 1, 2022; as a result, ITC stock could remain range-bound (and even go down closer to the Budget). Of course, steps towards bringing other forms of tobacco under taxation would be viewed positively while a sharp rise on cigarette to meet >75% tax threshold would be a significant negative.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, Check out latest IPO News, Best Performing IPOs, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1Nuvoco Vistas Corp Rating: Buy-Rise in margins to lessen gap with peers
2Telecom: Subscribers fell by 21 mn m-o-m in September
3Siemens Rating: Buy-A stable performance in the quarter by the firm