ICICI Lombard rating: Buy — Significant deal at not too high valuation

By: |
August 25, 2020 5:10 AM

Bharti AXA losses not best gauge of value creation; details to make picture clearer; ‘Buy’ retained with TP of Rs 1,600

We view this as a significant but not really game-changing ramp-up of I-Lom’s distribution capacity—accomplished at a not-too-onerous valuation.We view this as a significant but not really game-changing ramp-up of I-Lom’s distribution capacity—accomplished at a not-too-onerous valuation.

ICICI Lombard (I-Lom) has entered into a scheme of arrangement to amalgamate Bharti AXA General Insurance (BAGI)—a diversified general insurance business ~25% its size in gross direct premium income (GDPI) and 15–25% in terms of distribution node count.

I-Lom is making a fresh issue of 35.76 mn shares (7.3% dilution) to current BAGI promoters, which translates into two shares per 115 shares of BAGI. At I-Lom’s current market cap of ~Rs 588 bn (~6.1x FY20 NWP, 9.6x FY20 P/B), the share issue implies valuation of ~Rs 46 bn for BAGI (~2.3x FY20 NWP, 6.5x FY20 P/B—accounting for accumulated losses).

Arithmetically, this arrangement dilutes I-Lom’s FY20 EPS as BAGI made a loss of ~Rs 2.44 bn. However, given the acquisition likely entails immediate cost overhauls, this may not be the best gauge of value creation from the merger. We view this as a significant but not really game-changing ramp-up of I-Lom’s distribution capacity—accomplished at a not-too-onerous valuation.

We await detailed financials of the de-merged BAGI to build them in our estimates. Our chief concerns are twofold: (i) integration challenges and net capacity gain after elimination of redundancies; (ii) implications of this buy for its appetite for acquiring a monoline health insurance business, which could drive its dominance in every business that ‘matters’. I-Lom remains our preferred long-term BFSI top pick; reiterate Buy with a TP of Rs 1,600.

Goals clear, timeline less so
Mgmt was tight-lipped on the rationalisation timeline, only stating that it will be more than a year. They were forthcoming about the elements wherein they anticipate synergies. Other than economies of management/branding, they believe these may span: (i) renegotiation of distribution contracts from a position of greater BS strength as well as size; and (ii) integration of agency channels and OEM/product/data capabilities.

Last but not least, while gauging merger benefits one must contextualise overlap in product/distribution capabilities—specially considering shared strengths in auto OEM relationships. All said and done, BAGI’s cost ratio of 42% seems mainly a function of sub-optimal scale and therefore much easier to rectify.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Retail gets another investor on-board; General Atlantic to invest Rs 3,675 crore
2Abu Dhabi’s Mubadala in advanced talks to invest up to $1 bln in Reliance Retail-sources
3Reliance Jio seeks urgent spectrum auction, says further delay can lead to “serious quality of service issues”