Ayodhya case: Can’t undo Babar’s invasion, says Supreme Court as it reserves order on mediation

By: |
Updated: March 6, 2019 2:37:19 pm

Ram Mandir Ayodhya case hearing: The Supreme Court has reserved its order over whether the crucial Ram Janambhoomi-Babri Masjid land dispute in Ayodhya can be settled through mediation.

Ayodhya Case Live Verdict, Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid Case LiveRam Mandir hearing: Supreme Court has reserved verdict in Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid land dispute case

Ram Mandir Ayodhya case hearing highlights: The Supreme Court on Wednesday reserved its order over whether the crucial Ram Janambhoomi-Babri Masjid land dispute in Ayodhya can be settled through mediation. However, the court said it would pronounce its decision soon. During the hearing, the 5-judge apex court appeared divided over mediation route to settle the long-pending Ayodhya Ram Mandir dispute. Justice Bobde said the court is considering what is legal and can be binding on every party.

“You are looking at the outcome even before mediation is attempted. This is also about heart and mind and healing of relations,” Justice SA Bobde said reacting to submission by Hindu parties that mediation will be a failure.

“We cannot undo Babar invading etc. We can only decide what happens in the present,” Justice went on to add.

During the last hearing on February 26, the apex court had asked the contesting parties in the Ayodhya case to explore the possibility of resolving the decades old issue.

Even if there is “one per cent chance” of settling the dispute amicably, the parties should go for mediation, the Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice Ranjan Gogoi and comprising Justices S A Bobde, D Y Chandrachud, Ashok Bhushan and S A Nazeer, had observed.

“We are considering it (mediation) very seriously. You all (parties) have used the word that this matter is not adversarial. We would like to give a chance to mediation even if there is one per cent chance. We would like to know your (both parties) views on it. We do not want any third party to make a comment to jeopardise the entire process,” the bench had said.

While some of the Muslim parties agreed to the court’s suggestion on mediation, some Hindu bodies including the Ram Lalla Virajman opposed it, saying several such attempts have failed in the past.

(With PTI inputs)

Read More

Live Blog

Highlights

    12:20 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Sugget names for panel of mediators, SC tells parties involved

    The Supreme Court bench has asked all parties to suggest names for panel of mediators so that it can pass an order today only.

    12:15 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    SC reserves Ram Mandir Ayodhya mediation order

    The Supreme Court has reserved its order on mediation in Ram Mandir Ayodhya case. However, reports say the apex court could pass an order shortly from now.

    12:03 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Supreme Court reserves order

    Supreme Court reserves order over mediation in Ram Mandir Ayodhya case.

    12:02 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Govt has right to give land to whosoever it wants: Subramanian Swamy

    Subramanian Swamy, who has filed a writ in the matter, tells the Supreme Court that the Government has the right to give away land to whosoever it wants. Other parties are eligible for a compensation, Swamy says.

    11:59 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Supreme Court bench appears divided over mediation route

    5-judge Supreme Court bench  appears divided over mediation route to settle the long-pending Ayodhya Ram Mandir dispute. Justice Bobde says the court is considering what is legal and can be binding on everyone.

    11:45 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Can mediation bind millions of people, asks Supreme Court

    Will it be possible to bind millions of people to the outcome of mediation, Justice Chandrachud asks senior counsel Rajeev Dhavan.

    11:42 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    What the mediation law says?

    Senior Advocate Rajeev Dhavan discussing in court the nature of matters which can be decided through the process of mediation.

    11:37 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    No media reporting for mediation process, suggests SC

    The Supreme Court expresses that media reporting will be banned on ongoing mediation process. 

    11:31 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    This is also about heart and mind and healing of relations, says Justice Bobde

    You are looking at the outcome even before mediation is attempted. This is also about heart and mind and healing of relations, says Justice Bobde when Hindu parties asserted that mediation will be a failure

    11:28 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    We understand gravity of case: Justice Bobde

    We understand the gravity of the case. Past cannot be undone. We can only decide what happens in the present, says Justice Bobde

    11:24 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Can't undo Babar's invasion, says Justice SA Bobde

    We cannot undo Babar invading etc. We can only look into the current situation, says Justice SA Bobde.

    11:22 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    People will not agree to compromise, says lawyer

    As the proceedings begin, one of the lawyers opposes mediations. He says that even if the parties agree to resolve the issue amicably, people will not agreee to compromise.

    11:16 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Ram Mandir Ayodhya dispute hearing begins in Supreme Court

    Supreme Court has assembled and the hearing into the case has begun. The hearing was slightly delayed as the bar bid farewell to Justice AK Sikri who retires today. The top court is expected to decide whether a court-monitored mediation process can be initiated to resolve the decades-old dispute. This could run parallel to the legal proceedings.

    11:15 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Ram Mandir Ayodhya dispute hearing in Supreme Court

    Ram Mandir Ayodhya case hearing in Supreme Court

    As the Supreme Court hears the Ram Mandir Ayodhya case to decide whether there is any chance of mediation, here's what has happened in the decades-old case so far READ MORE

    11:01 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    What Archaeological Survey of India said in its 2003 report?

    The Archaeological Survey of India (ASI) had in a report submitted in 2003 suggested that a temple existed at the disputed site. The Babri Masjid was demolished in December 1992.

    11:01 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Ram Mandir Ayodhya case hearing LIVE Updates

    The  Supreme Court to begin hearing in Ram Mandir Ayodhya case is sometime from now. 

    10:19 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Fresh twist in Ayodhya case ahead of hearing in Supreme Court

    A fresh twist has emerged in long-pending contentious issue of Ayodhya Ram Mandir dispute.  Hindu Mahasabha has said it is not ready for any mediation in the matter. 

    09:07 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Ayodhya Ram Mandir case hearing LIVE Updates

    The politically sensitive Ram Mandir Ayodhya case may be referred for a court-monitored mediation by the Supreme Court, media reports say.

    08:06 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Ayodhya case hearing LIVE Updates

    During the last hearing on February 26, while some of the Muslim parties agreed to the court's suggestion on mediation, some Hindu bodies including the Ram Lalla Virajman opposed it, saying several such attempts have failed in the past.

    08:05 (IST)06 Mar 2019
    Ayodhya case hearing LIVE Updates

    The suggestion for mediation was mooted by Justice Bobde, during the hearing when both the Hindu and the Muslim sides were sparring over the veracity of documents related to the case which were translated by the Uttar Pradesh government and filed with the apex court registry.

    Ayodhya Case Live Verdict, Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid Case Live Ram Mandir hearing: Supreme Court to hear Ram Janmabhoomi-Babri Masjid land dispute caseRam mandir Ayodhya case hearing highlights: The Supreme Court on Wednesday will decided whether the crucial Ram Janambhoomi-Babri Masjid land dispute in Ayodhya can be settled through mediation. During the last hearing on February 26, the apex court had asked the contesting parties in the Ayodhya case to explore the possibility of resolving the decades old issue.
    Next Stories
    1Festive mood in Kamala Harris’s ancestral villages in Tamil Nadu ahead of her swearing-in as US Vice President
    2West Bengal Election 2021: Ranjan Banerjee, senior V-P of Aditya Birla Group, joins BJP
    3Budget Session 2021 Fact Sheet: From COVID test for MPs to schedule, all you need to know