‘Astrological incompatibility’ of horoscopes no excuse to retract from marriage promise: Bombay HC

By: |
Updated: September 21, 2021 3:23 PM

The Bombay High Court noted that ‘astrological incompatibility’ of horoscopes cannot be an excuse to resile from promise of marriage. 

The Bombay High Court noted that ‘astrological incompatibility’ of horoscopes cannot be an excuse to resile from promise of marriage. 

The Bombay High Court on Monday rejected a 32-year-old man’s plea seeking to be discharged from a rape and cheating case, noting that ‘astrological incompatibility’ of horoscopes cannot be an excuse to resile from promise of marriage. 

A single bench of Justice S K Shinde rejected the application filed by Avishek Mitra seeking to be discharged from the cheating and rape case registered against him by the suburban Borivali police on a complaint lodged by the woman, with whom he was in a relationship. 

Mitra’s advocate Raja Thakare had argued that the relations between the accused and the complainant could not be taken further due to “astrological incompatibility”. He argued that this was not a case of cheating and rape under the false pretext of marriage but a case of breach of promise.

Justice Shinde, however, refused to accept this contention and noted that there was material to suggest that since the beginning the accused had no intention of upholding his promise to marry the complainant.

“It is apparent that the applicant (Mitra) in the guise of astrological incompatibility of horoscopes, avoided the promise (of marriage). Thus, I am convinced that it is a case of false promise to marry which apparently vitiates the complainant’s consent,” the bench said.

Justice Shinde further noted that prima facie the court was of the view that Mitra assured the complainant that he would marry her when she approached the police just to avoid a case against him.

As per the case details, the accused and complainant knew each other since 2012 when they were working in a five-star hotel and were in a relationship. The complainant had alleged that on several occasions the accused had indulged in physical relations with her by promising marriage.

The complainant also claimed that when she had conceived and asked Mitra to marry her, he refused saying they were still young and forced her to abort the pregnancy.

In December 2012, when the accused started avoiding her, she lodged a police complaint. The police then called the accused and counselled the duo following which Mitra told the police in January 2013 that he would marry her.

However, within a few days the accused backtracked following which the police registered a case of rape and cheating, according to the prosecution.

Thakare had argued that there was absolutely no intent on Mitra’s part not to marry the complainant or that his promise to marry her was false.

“Had his intentions been bonafide and true, the applicant would not have resiled from his promise to marry the complainant later,” the bench said while rejecting his plea for discharge from the case.

(With PTI inputs)

Get live Stock Prices from BSE, NSE, US Market and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, Check out latest IPO News, Best Performing IPOs, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Financial Express is now on Telegram. Click here to join our channel and stay updated with the latest Biz news and updates.

Next Stories
1Rahul Gandhi meets party leaders from Gujarat, asks them to be prepared for assembly polls
2Narasimha Rao govt wanted to bring back Subhas Chandra Bose’s ashes, dropped idea after intelligence warning of riots: Netaji grandnephew
3Samajwadi Party govt opened fire at Lord Ram devotees and felicitated terrorists: Yogi Adityanath