Note ban: CMIE’s Vyas says 3.5 million jobs lost, PMEAC’s Bhalla demurs

By: | Published: September 15, 2018 6:04 AM

Demonetisation may have caused job losses of at least 3.5 million and the damaging impact on labour force was even starker, Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) chief executive Mahesh Vyas said on Friday, citing a CMIE survey that covers around 1.72 lakh households across the country.

Note ban, Demonetisation, CMIE, NSSO, Rajiv Kumar, NITI Aayog, India International CentrePrime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council member Surjit Bhalla, however, said according to the CMIE data, the share of women in the labour market is just 10%.

Demonetisation may have caused job losses of at least 3.5 million and the damaging impact on labour force was even starker, Centre for Monitoring Indian Economy (CMIE) chief executive Mahesh Vyas said on Friday, citing a CMIE survey that covers around 1.72 lakh households across the country. The note ban also hit the participation of young people in the labour force and hurt women more than men, he added.

Prime Minister’s Economic Advisory Council member Surjit Bhalla, however, said according to the CMIE data, the share of women in the labour market is just 10%. This is too abysmal to believe and compared with 25% pegged by previous National Sample Survey Office (NSSO) surveys, hinting that the CMIE data couldn’t be solely relied upon while gauging the true state of the employment in the country. He cautioned against over-interpretation of the employment scenario, based on incomplete and partial data.

Participating in a discussion on employment in India organised at the India International Centre on Friday, Vyas said the survey of people employed in the four months before and after demonetisation in November 2016 suggested job losses of 3.5 million following the note ban.

The losses were as much as 12.7 million in the one month after it, compared with the month before. “The story could be anywhere in between, that the initial shock was to the tune of 12.7 million, then it came down to 3.5 million or maybe there was some other factor behind it. But this was an opportunity that came by and since the survey were being held continuously and demonetisation happened in between… we see an impact on employment,” Vyas said.

The impact on the labour force was even much more significant. While the job losses could have been at least 3.5 million, the reduction in the labour force was to the tune of 15 million. That means people who were unemployed just before demonetisation stopped looking for jobs and the labour force shrank. The CMIE surveys also showed that while both the labour participation and unemployment rates were higher before demonetisation, labour participation declined after the note ban “and, therefore, the unemployment rate came down”, Vyas said.

According to Bhalla, the NSSO’s comprehensive household survey on jobs, the findings of which are expected to be announced in October, will separate the grain from the chaff and will be a much better indicator of employment scenario in the country. NITI Aayog vice-chairman Rajiv Kumar moderated the discussion. The government will bring out the first quarterly jobs data for urban areas in October, while the national data covering rural areas will be released annually.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Switch to Hindi Edition