Budget 2016: Is FM Arun Jaitley listening to Economic Survey’s suggestions?

By: |
Published: February 26, 2016 9:14:24 PM

Budget 2016: Too many journalists have, over the years, caused serious damage to their reputations by trying to get budget signals from the Economic Survey...

Indeed, while the government is a big proponent of direct cash transfers and the Jandhan Aadhar Mobile (JAM) trinity, as the Survey acknowledges, save for LPG, JAM itself is jammed. (PTI)Indeed, while the government is a big proponent of direct cash transfers and the Jandhan Aadhar Mobile (JAM) trinity, as the Economic Survey acknowledges, save for LPG, JAM itself is jammed. (PTI)

Budget 2016: Too many journalists have, over the years, caused serious damage to their reputations by trying to get budget signals from the Economic Survey – both, after all, are produced by the same ministry – yet, they persist. Like any good newspaper, the finance ministry too is divided into church and state – that’s news and views, for the uninitiated – and it is impossible to divine happenings in one from the other. Every year, Surveys recommend a reining in of subsidies and, one day later, the finance minister either raises them or fails to do anything – to that extent, this Survey is no different. Indeed, while the government is a big proponent of direct cash transfers and the Jandhan Aadhar Mobile (JAM) trinity, as the Survey acknowledges, save for LPG, JAM itself is jammed. Though the Survey has good data on Rs 1 lakh crore of subsidies to the rich – two thirds of the Rs 11,900 crore PPF subsidy goes to the top 2-3% of the population – some part of this is legislated; the Food Security Act (FSA) mandates that two thirds of the population gets vastly subsidized wheat and rice. While FSA is a UPA legacy, prime minister Modi’s decision to withdraw LPG subsidies – Rs 40,151 crore – to those earning over Rs 10 lakh applies to under 3% of the population. In other words, it’s prudent to assume the budget won’t do much on this front.

This is not to disparage the Survey since it has some top-class analysis should Modi chose to listen. On WTO, along the lines that FE has been espousing, it points to India’s policy of ‘lofty theologizing’ being misplaced and needing to cede to ‘mundane haggling over hides and hibiscuses’ – while India has made a big deal of needing special safeguard measures, the Survey says India needs this for a small fraction of its produce like milk, dairy, fruits and raw hides. Similarly, any PM looking to boost manufacturing has to be mindful of the problems “marketism without exit” creates – with free exit ensuring only the fittest survive, a 40-year old plant in the US is 8 times as large as a new one while this number is a mere 1.5 for India. As for encouraging formal jobs, the Survey echoes what Teamlease founder Manish Sabharwal wrote in FE – mandatory EPFO/ESI deductions take away 45% of a lowly paid employees’ salary. Perhaps the suggestion that will be taken most seriously is that relating to using part of RBI’s balances – Rs 2.2 lakh crore in the Contingency Fund and Rs 5.6 lakh crore in the Revaluation Account, among others – to partly fund the recapitalization of PSU banks; a cash-strapped government will welcome the ingenuity in ferreting out all cash that can possibly be labeled as spare in the government system. This would not be a bad idea if, as part of the cleaning up, there was a combination of privatizing banks and putting in fool-proof systems to prevent cronyism. The problem is that while the government’s mind is closed to privatization and not averse to piling onerous social obligations on PSU banks, bad loans are an integral part of growth –PSU banks have larger NPAs than private ones only because they lend to industry/infrastructure. Giving the government an easy way out from taking tough decisions can never be a good idea.

Get live Stock Prices from BSE and NSE and latest NAV, portfolio of Mutual Funds, calculate your tax by Income Tax Calculator, know market’s Top Gainers, Top Losers & Best Equity Funds. Like us on Facebook and follow us on Twitter.

Next Stories
1Economic Survey 2016: India needs to push up tax-GDP ratio; spend on health, education
2Economic Survey 2016: FDI up 31% at $24.8 billion during April-November
3Economic Survey 2016: Strong chance of downside risk in estimates