Fall in passenger numbers a new cause of concern for the railways

Written by Rajat Arora | New Delhi | Updated: Jun 17 2014, 14:45pm hrs
Railways fare hikeRailway Board has already asked the new government to increase passenger and freight fares. (Reuters)
Indian Railways, looking to hike fares in the upcoming Railway Budget, will still trim its passenger revenue estimate announced in the interim budget, given an unforeseen dip in the number of passengers. The national transporter had to cut its revenue projections from the passenger segment last fiscal also despite a 20% fare hike in January 2013, due to the low growth in passenger volumes.

The railways is finding it difficult to explain the 18-million dip in passenger volumes in the first two months of this fiscal.

Given that there is already a huge cross-subsidy from freight R26,000 crore last fiscal that sustains its passenger business, the current trend is indeed alarming if it displays the high price-elasticity of the passenger segment. The railways finances are in a shambles its operating ratio stood at 90.4% last year, indicating there is not enough left for replenishment of infrastructure let alone modernisation and expansion. If freight rates are increased too much, it could adversely impact the economy by jacking up industrial costs and thereby fanning inflation.

As the railways faces the peculiar problem of a decline in passenger numbers, the Railway Board is all set to trim the passenger revenue projections in the upcoming budget. In the first two months of the current fiscal, the railways has seen its passenger number falling by 18 million over last year.


The national carrier expected its passenger bookings to be around 8,800 million in FY15 compared with 8,535 million in the last fiscal. However, it is already clear that the estimate is unachievable. In April-May 2014 (in any year, these months are normally the peak season for the railways), passenger bookings stood at 1,377.82 million compared with 1,396.03 million in the same period a year earlier.

In the interim budget for FY15 presented by the UPA government, the passenger revenue was seen at R45,255 crore, up R7,500 crore over the revised estimate of FY14. It may be noted the revised estimate for last year was 11% lower than the initially budgeted R42,210 crore.

The railways is expecting to partially make up for the passenger revenue shortfall by increasing the fares of air-conditioned classes and also by increasing reservation and cancellation charges, sources said. Its a very strange problem that the (passenger) numbers have decreased during the peak the season. We are apprehensive that the number of passengers would fall further in the lean season. We have to take this into account in the upcoming budget, a senior railway ministry official said.

Budget estimates for goods, passenger, other coaching and sundry other earnings have been kept at R1,05,770 crore, R45,255 crore, R4,200 crore and R5,500 crore, respectively, for FY15.

Anticipating a healthier economic growth, the freight traffic target is proposed at 1,101 million tonnes for FY15, an increase of 49.7 million tonnes over last years revised estimate of 1,052 million tonnes.

Freight-wise we are looking very comfortable as we carried 180.63 million tonne of revenue-earning freight during April-May 2014, an increase of 8.79 million tonne over the same in the corresponding period last fiscal. Going by the trend we are expecting that the freight revenue could be higher than the budget estimates, the official added.

Struggling to keep its operational ratio under 90%, the Railway Board has already asked the new government to increase passenger and freight fares by 14% and 6.5%. If the fares are not hiked soon, then the railways would have to cut down the overall revenue projection by almost 10%.