Hyundai Grand i10 CRDi vs Toyota Etios Liva GD: Smart packaging

Posted online: Saturday, Nov 23, 2013 at 0000 hrs
The Hyundai Grand i10 has caused quite a stir with its combination of space, features and a frugal diesel engine. But can it outdo the established Toyota Etios Liva?

Whatís new?

Hyundai keeps pulling rabbits (or rather, hatchbacks) out of its hat. Its latest is the Grand i10, the fifth hatchback in its line-up. Now donít be fooled by the moniker, this isnít just a stretched-out i10óitís nothing less than an all-new car with a wheelbase stretched for India. The Grand i10 is easily the most restrained in terms of its external design compared to the rest of the cars in Hyundaiís line-up. The lines are much neater and crisper, and thereís very little of Hyundaiís ĎFluidicí design. The Grand looks like a more grown up and bolder Hyundai, further justifying its positioning. Also, itís got a new diesel engine under the hood. This 70bhp, 1,120cc engine is the first to be manufactured here in India at Hyundaiís plant in Chennai. The engine is essentially the 1.4-litre unit from the i20 with one cylinder less. But convincing buyers to opt for the Grand i10 wonít be a walk in the park. Sure, it is spacious, comfortable and comes with a diesel engine, but so does the Toyota Etios Liva. The Liva was also recently given a mid-life refresh, thanks to criticism the earlier car received from customers for feeling cheap. It now comes with a lighter shade of interiors with better plastics that go a long way in making the cabin feel more upmarket, greater sound insulation and more equipment. It really is much improved.

Both the hatchbacks have what Indian car buyers are looking for. So how does the new kid on the block fare against Toyotaís Liva?

What are they like to drive?

Drive the Grand i10 and youíll notice that the three-cylinder diesel flutters and vibrates a bit at low engine speeds. This is especially prominent in traffic when coasting, and you can immediately tell that itís a diesel engine under the hood. Put your foot down, however, and the engine smoothens up beautifully. There is a bit of hesitation at low speeds and it takes a bit to get moving, but once on the move, it feels like it has sufficient power for city driving. The mid-range feels peppy, the super-slick gearbox is easily the best in the class, and the Grand i10 settles into an effortless cruise when driven in a relaxed manner. But the Hyundai lacks the outright pull of the Liva, which has a bigger motor. In fact, it takes the Grand i10 a lazy 20.25 seconds to get to 100kph, and this can be a bit of an issue when youíre overtaking on the highway.

The Liva, with a 0-100 time of 15.86 seconds, is not an exceptional performer either, but itís much better than the Hyundai. It accelerates from a standstill in a linear manner and the responsive engine means that you will never really be waiting or wanting for more power in the city. Toyota has tailored the Liva for city drivingóitís got a light clutch (but not as light as the Grand i10ís) and a smooth shifting gearbox. And youíll enjoy driving the Liva on the highway more than the Grand. The Livaís 1.4-litre four-cylinder engine also remains largely vibe-free, but it does sound a bit gravelly and is the more audible of the two, getting progressively noisier as you build revs. And this is despite Toyota improving the insulation levels on the refreshed Liva.

Ride & handling

Hyundaiís Grand i10 is exceptionally light to drive for a diesel car. The super-light clutch pedal, electric power steering and gearshifts make this car a breeze to drive in the city. Its soft suspension does a good job of dispatching speed breakers and potholes, but it does thump over big, sharp bumps. And, on patchy roads, though it shows decent composure, itís nowhere near as stable as the Liva. The light steering, while great in the city, feels a bit vague at higher speeds.

At low speeds, the Livaís ride feels a bit jiggly over uneven surfaces, but itís not jarring. Up the pace and the ride smoothens out and is comfortable. It cruises with a flat and consistent poise, giving the driver a huge amount of confidence at speed. Itís nimble for its size and easy to punt around town, thanks to a tight turning circle and light electric steering. Itís not a thrill to drive either because of its average engine, but itís still better than the Grand.

What are they like inside?

Cabin quality is the Grand i10ís forte. The minute you step into the cabin, you feel like youíve spent your money well. Slide into the comfortable driverís seat and the first thing youíll notice is the chunky, leather-wrapped steering wheel that looks like it belongs on a much more expensive car, like a Hyundai Elantra. Finding a comfortable driving position isnít too hard, thanks to the seat height adjustment. The buttons on the steering wheel have a quality feel about them and the rotary knobs for the air-con have a premium knurled finish. The two-tone dash is well designed and the plastics are upmarket. The top half is finished in black, and the bottom half is beige, giving the cabin a premium feel. The dash-mounted gear lever is also superbly detailed. In fact, weíd say that the cabin is easily the best in its class.

The Liva, on the other hand, feels a full generation older in comparison to the Grand i10. Toyota has gone for a more function-over-form design with the cabin. However, the carmaker has recently done away with the flat, thin seats of the older car and replaced them with a more comfortable set. Its driverís seat has height adjustment too. The improved door pads and the faux wood trim go a long way in lifting the ambience of this plain-Jane cabin. The central instruments get icy-blue backlighting, but we did miss having a rev counter. The new air-con controls feel much better and have a nice tactile feel about themóan improvement over the previous ones, and the new music system is a lot less tacky than the previous unit. There are also plenty of cubby holes around the cabin for your knick-knacks.

The big advantage the Liva has is that it is wider than the Grand, so seating three abreast is easier. Thigh support is very good and the seats are set at a well reclined angle. The Grand, with the additional legroom, is decent too; in fact, maximum legroom is similar, at 89 mm and 90 mm for the Hyundai and Toyota, respectively.

When you put the two cars together and compare cabin quality, itís the Hyundai that comes out on top, and by a long margin. Itís got that feel-good factor that the Liva simply lacks.

Equipment & safety

The Liva is decently equipped. Weíve tested the GD variant, which comes with decent kit. Itís got 12-spoke alloy wheels, power windows, central locking, tilt-adjust steering, ABS with EBD, keyless entry, optional airbags, and a two-DIN music system with CD, MP3 and USB connectivity. You can only get Bluetooth on the top-spec V petrol variant, as is the case with steering-mounted controls and an aux-in port.

The Hyundai Grand is packed to the gills with features. Weíve tested the top Asta variant of the Grand and it comes with more than you will ever need. It gets a music system with CD, Aux-in, Bluetooth, USB, and 1 GB of internal storage, electrically adjustable mirrors, steering-mounted audio controls, push button start, tilt steering, cooled glovebox, driver-seat height adjust, rear AC vents, a MID (multi-information display) screen, a leather-wrapped steering wheel, rear parking sensors, ABS, front fog lamps, and two airbags.

Grand i10 Asta

Engine and performance

Size 1120cc, 3 cylinders

Peak power 70bhp@4000rpm

Peak torque 16.3kgm@2750rpm

0-100 kph 20.25 seconds

Top speed 149 kph

Economy 17.5 kpl

Tank 43 litres

Range 753 km

Etios Liva GD

Engine and performance

Size 1364cc, 4 cylinders

Peak power 68bhp@3800rpm

Peak torque 17.33kgm@1800rpm

0-100 kph 15.86 seconds

Top speed 151 kph

Economy 16.9 kpl

Tank 45 litres

Range 761 km