Net Edition
Financial express logo
Wednesday, February 28, 2007
 
 
 
  SEARCH FE
Financial Express
Web
  FE ARCHIVE
   Search by Date
  INSIDE FE PRINT
 
  Home
 Front Page
 Corporates & Markets
 Latest News
 Stocks
 Fe Insight
 Politics
 Edits & Columns
 International
 From The Economist
 Economy
 Fe 360
 Fe Centres
 Fe Web Specials
 Sme World
 Fe 500
 Best Banks In India
  Letters To The Editor
  All Headlines
  SERVICES
 
  Personalised Predictions
  CHANNELS
 
  Astrology
  Shopping
  Tenders 
  Express Classifieds
  ExpressQnA 
  Express Estates
  Express Money
  Express Travel
  GROUP SITES
 
  Expressindia
  The Indian Express
  Screen
  City Newslines
  Kashmir Live
  Express Cricket
  Loksatta
  Lokprabha
  Express Computer
  North American
Edition [Print]
 
 
  The Financial Express
  The Indian Express
  SUBSCRIPTIONS
 
  Free Newsletter
  Wireless Express
  SYNDICATIONS
 
  RSS FeedsRSS Feeds
-->

 
LATEST NEWS
Economy
Meanwhile, poor question 'Shining India'
Posted online: Wednesday, February 28, 2007 at 1539 hours IST
Updated: Thursday, March 01, 2007 at 1053 hours IST
 
Send Feedback   E-mail this story   Print this story
IMAGE_CAP_1
KALWARI, FEBRUARY 28:  Wedged in between a posh hotel, a modern highway and a booming technology corridor, Kalwari, village of open sewers and sporadic power is at the front-end of a controversy about who benefits from economic growth in India.

"It's good our country progresses," said Raj Singh, a 41-year-old cook, as he walked through dirt streets in the lower caste district of Kalwari, about 55 km from New Delhi.

Advertisement
"But that development should happen in my village. Here the poor are getting poorer. We are forgotten. Nobody comes here."

The Congress-led government presents its annual budget on Wednesday, promising more of the breakneck growth that has seen gleaming high-rises spring up in booming cities across India where millions are employed in services like call centres.

But behind the headlines of 'Shining India' are worries that growth is failing to trickle down to the poor and the Left-backed government is concerned that a by-product of the boom--a rising inflation rate--is making many people poorer.

"It's rather like if the US government focused its growth strategy on making New York brokers wealthier," said D K Joshi, principal economist at domestic credit rating agency CRISIL.

"There are millions in call centres that benefit from growth. But India's population is massive and a huge chunk of the population is not benefiting," said Joshi.

The rural sector, for example, accounts for two-thirds of India's billion-plus population but is growing at less than one third of the pace of the overall economy.

A TALE OF TWO REGIONS

Outside Kalwari, men sat by a main road. Some picked up rubbish scraps. They supplemented their meagre incomes, they said, by occasionally being picked up in a lorry to attend political rallies in Delhi.

Kalwari is a bus ride away from Gurgaon, a town of call centres, new suburbs and one of the largest McDonalds in India. But few farmers thought they, or their children, would ever find work there.

"We are uneducated, unskilled people. Who will take us?" said Balvan Yadav, a 32-year-old farmer.

On the opening of the budget session, President A PJ Abdul Kalam told Parliament the government was committed to 'inclusive development'.

It has introduced measures to help India's 260 million poor, from programmes that guarantee jobs for rural poor to food subsidies. But many of the funds do not reach their target through poor implementation or corruption.

Raj Singh's hut has no electricity or running water. Children play near stinking gutters. The caste divisions of a village so close to the capital also underscores how obstacles to modernisation in India are hard to overcome.

Singh has two children. One, a girl, was married off at 15. His other child, a boy, goes to school, 'if the teachers turn up' and otherwise works to supplement Singh's Rs 2,000 a month income by helping out in the fields.

India has higher levels of malnourished children than Sub-Saharan Africa, according to a recent survey backed by the UN Children's Fund (UNICEF), and some key health indicators have hardly budged despite the boom.

The city-rural divide has widened in India and was reflected in a 2004 election when millions of rural poor voted against the free market reforms of the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party.

This year, reforms from the Congress-led coalition like special economic zones to encourage industrial development have been suspended due to a backlash from farmers.

And on Tuesday, the Congress party was ousted from power in Punjab and Uttarakhand in elections reflecting voter anger over inflation and economic reforms.

"The question now is not growth, but the nature of the growth. Who will benefit?" said Joshi.

Send Feedback   E-mail this story   Print this story





 
Full Coverage
RBI Annual Report
Economic Survey '05-06
Railway Budget '06
Economic Reforms
Indo-Eu Summit: 2005
India Empowered
Reliance Empire Divided
Davos 2006
JJ Irani Committee On Company Law
Ready For Vat?
Run-Up To Foreign Trade Policy 2005-06
Run Up To Budget 2007-08
Rbi Annual Policy 2007-08
Run-Up To Budget 2005-06
Ambani Vs Ambani
Ear To The Ground
The Idea Exchange
RBI Monetary Policy
Walk The Talk
WTO Special
Outcome Budget: 2005-06