In 1933, my grandfather left Mumbai to take up his first job as a teacher in a Marathi school in Karachi. In those days, the two cities were part of the then-Bombay Presidency under British rule. In 2010, I flew from Mumbai to Karachi and will never forget the expression of the taxi driver when he asked me which airline I was flying. When I responded “Pakistan International Airlines,” his reaction was as if I had just turned into an alien.
Perhaps there is a certain alienating effect that comes with six decades of practical isolation. Today, there are a mere four flights per week between the world’s second and sixth most populous nations, and one land crossing in over 3,000 kilometres of contiguous border. There, at Wagah, the daily ritual that accompanies the lowering of the flags is a particularly unique piece of theatre whose enduring popularity owes as much to the mutual curiosity that exists between Indians and Pakistanis as it does to shared suspicion.
The ceremony also offers a clue as to where both countries’ economic priorities should lie, as the mutual fascination we share with our neighbours serves also as a stark reminder of the economic benefits that both countries stand to reap if we were to allow that suspicion to drop.
Today, trade between the two countries is minimal, and what does get traded is conducted via intermediaries in places such as Dubai, adding thousands of miles of detour and exacting a huge toll on transaction costs, profitability and environmental sustainability, not to mention entrepreneurial spirit. As identified by the World Economic Forum’s Global Agenda Council on Pakistan, India has a middle class of about 300 million people with rising purchasing power that matches that of south-eastern Europe, while Pakistan’s middle class is approximately 30 million. A 10% penetration into the Indian middle class market would double the market size for Pakistani companies and businesses. The potential for transfer of technology from India to Pakistan and bilateral cultural exchange of fashion, music and films is enormous.
Consider the example set by China and Taiwan, two