Indian Express

Express India

Screen

Loksatta

Express Cricket

Kashmir Live

Biz Publications
 
Make this your homepage | RSS


FACE 2 FACE Do we need software patents?

They offer valuable property protection

Saikrishna Rajagopal

Posted: Monday, Aug 11, 2008 at 2122 hrs IST
Updated: Monday, Aug 11, 2008 at 2122 hrs IST


Font Size

Print

Feedback

Email

Discuss

: The policy foundation of a strong patent system is threefold—to provide appropriate incentives to foster innovation, to facilitate broad dissemination technological advances to the public, and to create a sustainable innovation cycle in which new technologies can be profitably commercialised.

The Indian patent system meets these key objectives, providing appropriate protection for innovation in all industries, including the IT sector. The current law prohibits patenting of abstract ideas and computer programs per se. This precludes extending patent protection to software that does not have a physical application that is both new and useful, while allowing for protection of true innovations that reflect a clear technological advancement or benefit. Besides, the law provides mechanisms and safeguards, whereby even broad or frivolous patents can be reduced in scope or even cancelled under certain conditions, to prevent any misuse or abuse.

The government’s recent efforts to revise and improve the internal guidance mechanism provided to patent examiners, is a welcome move towards achieving clarity and consistency in the patent examination system. Contrary to the rhetoric adopted by a small group who oppose this effort, the proposed changes do not seek to alter the law, but rather to effectively implement current law. Opponents seek to confuse the legal issues by mischaracterising the proposed revisions to the Patent Office’s internal procedural guidelines as an indirect effort to change substantive patent law. Their efforts should be strongly rejected, as the proposed changes will benefit domestic companies as well, across all industries, including those in the Indian IT sector.

Today, India is a major hub for innovation and creativity. This is visible in practically all fields of technology, be it polymers, biotechnology-based applications, heavy industry, or software. While a significant part of the IT industry caters to application R&D based on existing software, major players are constantly investing in R&D into new software applications. India’s biggest strength is its large pool of young talented researchers, engineers, scientists, academic scholars, entrepreneurs, and science and technology students. The growth of Indian entrepreneurship is evident in the recent spurt of patent applications that are being filed both in India and abroad by Indian entities, including private entities, universities and government owned or controlled research institutions.

The Indian IT industry could contribute enormously to the country’s GDP, if an effective IPR eco-system is put in place. While large Indian IT companies are now able to compete globally, there are a number of small and...

More from eXpert Bytes

Single Page Format 1 - 2 - Next
Discuss this story on expressindia forums

Post Comments

Comments: (Limit 3,000 characters)
Name
Message
Email ID
Subject
TERMS OF USE:
The views, opinions and comments posted are your, and are not endorsed by this website. You shall be solely responsible for the comment posted here. The website reserves the right to delete, reject, or otherwise remove any views, opinions and comments posted or part thereof. You shall ensure that the comment is not inflammatory, abusive, derogatory, defamatory &/or obscene, or contain pornographic matter and/or does not constitute hate mail, or violate privacy of any person (s) or breach confidentiality or otherwise is illegal, immoral or contrary to public policy. Nor should it contain anything infringing copyright &/or intellectual property rights of any person(s).
I agree to the terms of use.

Comments
» Where is the proof?
Posted by Venkatesh Hariharan on 2008-08-11 17:32:05.705618+05:30
This article offers zero evidence for the claim that software patents lead to innovation. As I mention in my piece, a lot of innovation in software happened before patents became the norm in some countries. Also, the author claims that the manual does not seek to make substantive changes to the law. However, even a toddler can read between the lines on what's happening.We believe that this is not in consonance with the will of the Indian Parliament, which explicitly rejected the following language from the Patent Amendment Act 2005:“a computer programme per se other than its technical application to industry or a combination with hardware [emphasis mine]; a mathematical method or a business method or algorithms.” Since this amendment was rejected, Clause 3(k) of the Indian Patent Act reverted to the original, which says, “A mathematical or business method or a computer programme per se or algorithms are not patentable”.On reviewing the Draft Patent Manual, we find that it seeks to make technical applications of software patentable. The relevant section of the Draft says:Draft Manual 4.11.74.A mathematical method is one which is carried out on numbers and provides a result in numerical form (the mathematical method or algorithm therefore being merely an abstract concept prescribing how to operate on the numbers) and not patentable. However, its application may well be patentable, for example, in Vicom/Computer-related invention [1987] 1 OJEPO 14 (T208/84) the invention concerned a mathematical method for manipulating data representing an image, leading to an enhanced digital image. Claims to a method of digitally filtering data performed on a conventional general purpose computer were rejected, since those claims were held to define an abstract concept not distinguished from a mathematical method. However, claims to a method of image processing which used the mathematical method to operate on numbers representing an image can be allowed. The reasoning was that the image processing performed was a technical (i.e. non- excluded) process which related to technical quality of the image and that a claim directed to a technical process in which the method used does not seek protection for the mathematical method as such. Therefore the allowable claims as such went beyond a mathematical method. In other words, the net effect of the patent manual will be to make software a patentable commodity, by allowing patents on technical applications of software. This is exactly what the Indian parliament rejected during the Patent Amendment Act 2005.

Flowers & Cakes DeliveryExpress Classifieds
Post and view free classifieds ad
Express Astrology
Know what's in the stars for you