India vs England Mumbai Test: M S Dhoni suffers humiliating defeat on spin-friendly track

Comments print
Agencies: Mumbai, Nov 26 2012, 10:00 IST
Monty Panesar.jpg
In a Test that had been hyped-up to a huge degree by the India captain M S Dhoni reposing full faith in his spinners and batsmen to impose on England a crushing defeat on a spin-friendly pitch, which he had demanded as soon as he won the first Test, the exact opposite of what he planned, happened.

England scored a paltry 57 runs, to ease to 10-wkt confidence-boosting victory vs hosts India in Mumbai Test.

While Cook scored 18, he was ably supported by Nick Compton, who got off to a cracker of an innings, nipping in the bud M S Dhoni's efforts to use spin from the first ball against England in their second innings. He scored 30.

With India all out for 142, England needed just 57 runs to win the Mumbai Test.

A woeful display by India with both bat and ball allowed England to heap humiliation on India by winning the Mumbai Test with ease.

Considering that Dhoni had asked for, and received, a rank spin-friendly pitch, that had all the experts and former players like Steve Waugh saying this was not fair, failure to check the English batting and deal with the slow turners of Monty Panesar and Graeme Swann, led to the infliction of an embarrassing defeat, that too at home.

This has surely put a question mark on exactly how able Indian batsmen are playing against both pace and spin – on current match stats, the answer is clearly negative and cancels out the first Test victory, that was

... contd.

Ads by Google
   1 | 2 | 3 | Next
Previous Story  At the receiving end Next Story  India vs England 2012: M S Dhoni blames spinners for Mumbai Test loss
Reader's Comments (7)| Post a Comment

cricket fan

panditarjun | 26-Nov-2012Reply | Forward
2 things need to be done asap 1st remove mr fletcher he is good for nothin 2nd some players need to go back to ranji and play and kindly send B team for the test in kolkata and am 100%sure they will do better there was no will from any of indian batsman to stay at the wicket and they played all cross batted shots .ashwin,bhaj,sachin,yuvi,veeru should be replaced by mishra,chawla,rahane,tiwary,rohit or badri immediately seniors should go back to domestic cricket and get back their technique but most important if mr fletcher stays india will never win any test series in india or overseas serious steps need to be taken or the worst is yet to come when india travels to SA

blame whom?

seshapathi | 26-Nov-2012Reply | Forward
it is the group of selectors and MS dhoni going to test without a leg spinner. history tels that England team is always a weak against leggies. What made MSD to go with bajji on cricketing ground realities only bajji is good friend of MSD.rahul or amit mishra even chawla might have given better performance. bhajji taken two tailenders wicket only msd want bhajji on bowiling chart of wicket takers. On performance of MSD only he can take a call to play for tests or not.

the value of quality test players

hemanth | 26-Nov-2012Reply | Forward
hope MS and indian team youngsters, realise the value of dravid and laxman. Sachin has been overhyped, while these two veterans were hounded out without respect. Our youngsters from Virat to yuvraj in the middle order, do not know how to build an patient innings on bowler friendly spin tracks. This is a well deserved wake up call for the Indian team selectors, as the bowlers have been found short, and in fact it is a matter of concern that the spin cupboard is bare and the middle order is weak....Time to plan for the long term india...

Post your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name *
Email *
Message *
 
captcha
please enter the above characters in the box below