If reading statutes is all, robots would be judges: Chief Justice Mohit Shah

Comments print
Express news service :Mumbai, Dec 03 2012, 03:47 IST
Less than a week of a magistrate from Palghar in Thane being transferred on “administrative grounds” days after a row over the arrest of two girls for posting a Facebook comment, Chief Justice of the Bombay High Court Mohit Shah on Sunday said judges while maintaining consistency, should apply the law according to facts and circumstances of each case and use their “sensitivity and common sense”.

Addressing a gathering of around 250 judges from magistrate and district courts from the state, at Uttan in Thane, Chief Justice Shah said, “If it was only about reading provisions of a statute, judging would have been left to robots and machines.”

The Bombay HC had transferred Ramchandra Bagade, Joint Civil Judge, Junior Division and Judicial Magistrate First Class, Palghar to Pachora in Jalgaon district last week on “administrative grounds”. The transfer came a week after the girls from Palghar, arrested on November 18 for posting an FB comment criticising the shutdown after the death of Shiv Sena Chief Bal Thackeray, were produced in Bagade’s court. Incidentally, Bagade had also granted bail to 10 Shiv Sainiks accused of vandalising the clinic of the uncle of one of the girls.

Speaking at the launch of a project, ‘Disseminating Knowledge Among Judicial Officers’, at the Maharashtra Judicial Academy (MJA) and the Indian Mediation Centre and Training Institute at Uttan, Chief Justice Shah said the same sections of the law would apply to a father who breaks a chair at a hospital after his only child

... contd.

Ads by Google
   1 | 2 | 3 | Next
Previous Story  Quota: Gehlot can’t sit on the fence for long Next Story  Indian patents worry Bangladesh
Reader's Comments| Post a Comment

Be the first to comment.

Post your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name *
Email *
Message *
 
captcha
please enter the above characters in the box below