FE Editorial : Beware the innuendo

Nov 19 2012, 01:17 IST
Comments 0
SummaryOne of the underlying points in most anti-graft movements is that we need to go back to the old days, where PSUs held sway, if we want to reduce corruption.

Cost overruns donít axiomatically mean corruption

One of the underlying points in most anti-graft movements is that we need to go back to the old days, where PSUs held sway, if we want to reduce corruption. So, for instance, if ONGC were to be drilling for gas in the KGD6 basin instead of Reliance, we wouldnít have had the kind of gold-plating of costs charges that are being levelled today. If Coal India were to be mining the coal, we wouldnít have had the Coalgate scam; if the Airports Authority of India were to be running the Delhi airport, we wouldnít have had the kind of allegations weíve seen against DIAL Ö Each of the allegations needs to be investigated in a thorough manner, but itís important in all of this to put aside the myth that PSUs have delivered, and consistently. Private telcos have beaten BSNL in terms of rural penetration, and without the kind of generous grants BSNL gets; Reliance and Cairn have beaten ONGC in terms of their new oil/gas finds; and Air India ceased to carry the bulk of Indiaís flying public several years ago Ö

Data put out by the ministry of statistics and programme implementation, carried in FE last week, is even more damning. On the face of it, PSUs are doing a great job in terms of implementing projects at budget. For a sample of 198 projects, which entailed an initial investment of at least R1,000 crore, the cost overrun has averaged a mere 16%. This average, however, masks the fact that the escalation in costs for more than a third of the projects is closer to 60%. And even this doesnít provide the full picture since, in far too many cases, the costs data is simply not updated. NTPCís Barh power plant, for instance, is still estimated to cost R8,693 crore, although it was conceived way back in 2003 and is six years behind schedule already. The estimate for the Bongaigaon power plant too hasnít been updated, although it is 40 months behind schedule. And since there could be further delays before a project is up and running, itís possible the final cost could be even higher. Of course there are projects for which fresh estimates have been computedóthe expansion of RINLís steel plant, for example, will now cost R12, 291 crore and not R8,692 crore as envisaged earlier. But the ministryís data shows

Single Page Format
Ads by Google

More from Edit & Columns

Reader´s Comments
| Post a Comment
Please Wait while comments are loading...