Column: Pricing blues

Feb 17 2014, 00:18 IST
Comments 0
SummarySocialist pricing leads to crony capitalism

Any country where there are celebratory headlines about the inflation rate having Ďplunged to a low value of only 8.79%í needs its collective head examined. People are already urging Rajan to cut interest rates and encourage growth. It is not only the politicians but even the private sector leaders who should know better. India used to have a high reputation as a low-inflation country. Never before has it had four years of persistently high inflation with the government doing nothing to correct the inflation trend but secretly approving its redistributive effects for its rural vote gatherings strategy. Perhaps in that if in nothing else, UPA-2 has achieved its policy aims. It wanted to punish the urban areas for having enjoyed the fruits of liberal reforms. The weapon was food price inflation. The NAC designed this policy. Now, hopefully, it will ensure the defeat of Congress in 2014.

The perverse nature of the Indian political economy consists of a deliberate misunderstanding of how prices allocate resources and how any neglect of the economic logic of pricing imposes costs somewhere on someone in an unintended fashion. Politicians believe, or at least pretend to, that any itemógoods or serviceósold through the state must have a price which bears no relation to costs. As we see in Delhi, the AAP believes that water or electricity must be priced popularly rather than in any way which would make sense in terms of the environment or the economy. Water is scarce and should be used sparinglyónot given away at low prices, especially to the better off.

If Kejriwal goes into a dhaba, he pays whatever he is asked for his paratha and chhole . Why then does he think that goods or services where the Delhi government has any say should be priced below cost ? For decades, state power companies have been making losses and passing the burden on to taxpayers via deficits. Lately, some economic sense has come into this sector where private companies have been providing power at cost-plus prices. In Delhi, the result has been fewer outages which itself is worth paying for as I can attest being an occasional consumer. Now, Kejriwal wants us to go back to the bad old days of loss-making power supply and frequent outages. If he knew any economics, he would know that the price should cover the availability of the commodity . It would

Single Page Format
Ads by Google

More from Edit & Columns

Reader´s Comments
| Post a Comment
Please Wait while comments are loading...