Latest trends in government finances on both the revenue and the expenditure front are encouraging with revenues in line with estimates and expenditures below budgeted rates, thereby resulting in a marginal fiscal surplus in December. While, admittedly, there is some seasonality in the December tax numbers, the key factor responsible for the improvement in government finances is a larger-than-expected compression in expenditure. A continuation of trends since September now makes the government’s 5.3% deficit target seem more achievable. This is in contrast to trends a few months ago when expectations were of a deficit close to 5.9% levels. Key to watch in the next few weeks are (1) divestments—the new norms and pricing are making a difference, (2) telecom re-auction, (3) further expenditure compression, and (4) extent of subsidy deferral.
Upon a closer look at the numbers, one finds that government expenditure remained in check for the fourth consecutive month with spending in December down by 9% yoy. Cumulatively, during April-December, total expenditure was R9,911 billion, up 10.6% yoy and 67% of budget estimates. While the run-rate on expenses is below the budgeted rate of 13.1%, key points to note are: (1) the subsidy estimates in the budget have little provision for fuel subsidy for FY13, and (2) expenditure compression is largely due to plan expenditure, which is up 6.9% versus a targeted rate of 22.1%.
On the expenditure front, as non-Plan expenditure is largely ‘committed’ expenditure—i.e. spending on interest, wages, subsidies and defence, there is little room for manoeuvrability. Additionally, the current run rate of 12.2% is higher than the budgeted growth rate of 8.7%. Thus, apart from a bit of ‘tweaking’ on the non-Plan side, one could see a further compression of Plan expenditure to help enable the government meet its estimates. Key to note is that the finance ministry has directed ministries to cap spending in the January-March quarter to 33% of total funds allocated.
Moving on to subsidies, the government had pegged the total subsidy outlay at R1,900 billion. However, as is now well known, the FY13 outlay of R436 billion on fuel subsidies has been utilised to the