Bank rally ready to be marked-to-market

Font Size

Print

Feedback

Email

Discuss

Related Articles

‘People still prefer piracy to paying for world ci...

: James Saft

US bank operating earnings are going to have a hard time outrunning credit losses, making the massive rally in bank shares look ready to be marked-to-market. A series of positive statements about profitability in the early part of the year from major US banks, notably Bank of America, Citigroup and JP Morgan helped to spring a rally in the beaten down sector, as investors bet that with government assistance they could earn their way out of their troubles.

The KBW bank index has enjoyed a blistering rally, rising 51% from its March 8 low, though it is still down almost 40 percent from where it ended 2008. To be comfortable with that, you have to believe two difficult things; that investors will value the earnings banks are now making as if they were sustainable and that banks won’t be swamped by credit losses and potential forced dilutions of shareholders.

“We are unconvinced that the banks have turned a corner,” FBR Capital Markets analyst Paul Miller wrote in a note to clients. “Investors who believe that the recent financial rally is here to stay expect that most banks will remain profitable.

We expect that profitability at these banks will be driven by favorable fixed-income trading revenues, as well as mortgage banking revenues.”

In some ways, balance sheets aside, it’s a pretty good time to be a bank in America. Competition has thinned out and margins should fatten commensurately. US bank profits from trading and mortgage banking are both problematic. Trading income, because it varies wildly, is hard to predict and hard to value.

If the past two years has taught us anything, it’s that paper profits can evaporate and risks can be hard to spot.

On the positive side, the fact that banks are now putting less balance sheet to work as market makers means that those banks which still operate can make considerably more on the difference between where they buy and sell securities. But given the huge uncertainty about who will be around in a year’s time, especially given the by its nature unpredictable role of government, its hard to know how much competition there will be or even how much capital banks will be forced to hold against trading activities.

Loan collecting blues