Pak Spring?

Comments print
Shekhar Gupta : Jan 16 2012, 03:06 IST
Exactly a decade ago, speaking at the inauguration of the Daily Times, a liberal new publication edited by Najam and Jugnu Sethi, pillars of Pakistani media, I got myself into some trouble, which is not unusual given my chronic foot-in-the-mouth disease. This was early 2002. We were in a war-like situation following the attack on Parliament. Pervez Musharraf was fully in control, Nawaz Sharif and Benazir Bhutto were in exile, and all democracy in suspension.

I said to a hall filled with Lahore’s liberal elite at the Pearl Continental, that one reason we were always struggling in our bilateral relations was that we were still governed by poorly evolved systems. So Pakistan, I said, was as imperfect a dictatorship as India was an imperfect democracy. Explanation: the Pakistanis had not quite denied their citizens all the freedoms that genuine dictatorships like North Korea, China, Iraq and Libya (then) did, or they would not have me, an Indian, saying rude things about their rulers to a full hall in Lahore. Similarly, I said, we in India had not yet quite succeeded in giving our people all the freedoms and rights that a classical, liberal democracy ought to. This, by the way, was also the year of the Gujarat riots. Both countries, I added, needed to move in opposite directions, we to make our democracy more perfect, and Pakistan, to make its dictatorship even more imperfect. Then, we might reach a middle ground where we, our establishments and peoples, find it easier to

... contd.

Ads by Google
   1 | 2 | 3 | Next
Previous Story  Creative hotspot Next Story  2012: Turbulent year ahead for global stocks
Reader's Comments (4)| Post a Comment

focus

lilly | 11-Sep-2012Reply | Forward
i l my india

Pak Spring

Ram Subramanian | 08-Mar-2012Reply | Forward
One can only hope that this trend continues... it can only augur well for the region. In reply to sweety's comment, have you heard the saying Absolute Power Corrupts? This is exactly what people started fearing once the Anna movement went beyond protest and stated advocating mob power to get issues resolved. This will only lead to a state of total anarchy. We have to work within the democratic setup... it will change, maybe slowly, but change it will. Issues affecting the nation (esp. one with so many disparate peoples, languages, cultures) cannot be solved overnight nor is a deadline that someone sets practical (as happened with Anna). My two cents or rather rupees on the issue.

Pak Spring

Raghav Shukla | 06-Feb-2012Reply | Forward
Well said Shekhar.Indeed impressive write up.

Post your Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Name *
Email *
Message *
 
captcha
please enter the above characters in the box below