Indian Express

Express India

Screen

Loksatta

Express Cricket

Kashmir Live

Biz Publications
 
| Make this your homepage | Feedback

TODAY'S COLUMNIST

Column The multilingual imperative

Manish Sabharwal
Posted online: Saturday , July 05, 2008 at 21:06 hrs
Updated On: Saturday , July 05, 2008 at 21:06 hrs


Font Size

Print

Feedback

Email

Discuss
Rate This Article
1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10
Rating:  0

Kancha Ilaiah is a leading Dalit rights advocate who believes that India’s school education system has two distinct structures; regional language education is meant for Dalit-Bahujan children while English education is mostly meant for the upper castes. His belief that this division is mirrored in government and private schools inspired him to spearhead a campaign to switch government schools in Andhra Pradesh from regional languages to English as the medium of instruction. He believes that a) language is different from culture, b) most of the “mother tongue gang” educates their children in private English schools and, c) traditionally disadvantaged groups need English because it is a vocational skill.

This feisty professor of political science at Osmania University saw recent success with the AP government agreeing to introduce English from the sixth standard in 6500 schools. The next phase of his campaign advocates starting English earlier (Kindergarten) and convincing other states. His more controversial thoughts involve asking the State reorganization committee for a review of linguistic states and adopting English as the national language because “this will allow the poor and productive masses to learn the language of administration and globalization”.

I work for a people supply chain company running out of inventory. I am agnostic to the dogmatic, emotional and ideological issues that sabotage healthy debate around education and training reform; private vs government delivery, traditional vs. child centric curriculums, long term vs short term courses, accreditation vs. outcome centric and English vs. regional instruction. All we should care about is employable people and as Deng Xiaoping quipped, if a cat catches mice does it matter if it is black or white? India has so far failed Noah’s test (predicting rain is not enough, building an ark is all that matters) and we should act immediately to improve the employability of our youth.

The employment prospects for English speaking youth are 400% better than those from regional language schools. They not only have geographic choices (labour mobility is low for youth who are not multi-lingual) but have an unfair advantage by speaking the language of business. Language is an emotional subject but just as the adoption of standards like windows, railway gauges, internet protocols, etc lead to greater inter-operability and usage, English has integrated our diversity. As a country with 22 languages in our constitution, English is a “subsidiary official language” that is used for most official and inter-state correspondence. Historian Ramachandra...

Single Page Format 1 - 2 - 3 - Next
Ads by Google

Post Comments

Comments: (Limit 3,000 characters)
Name
Message
Email ID
Subject
TERMS OF USE:
The views represented here are not neccesarily endorsed by www.financialexpress.com and its allied websites. All messages will be moderated and no message that has inflammatory, abusive, derogatory language or any language deemed unfit for publication by the editor will be displayed. Though it will be endeavoured that as many messages as possible be displayed, there will be time lag between the submission and publication of the messages. The website reserves the right to publish or reject any message.
I agree to the terms of use.

Comments
» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:17:42.261569+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:17:31.369113+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:17:18.749762+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:17:16.581058+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:17:11.20686+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:17:08.092986+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:16:59.925228+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» english education
Posted by prof.s.divakaran Jodhpur University on 2008-08-04 04:16:46.164858+05:30
This column has commended Kancha Iliah whose writings are mostly uninformed and inflammatory.How he continues in the Political Science dept in Osmania U is surprising.The man is a bigot. Is he prepared to foot the cost of educating one child in English? We do not need Kancah Iliahs for the dalits, we need late Rajaji who suggested better schooll education with afternoon timings so tht the rural parents are enabled to send the children to school instead of making them work in the field. No more Kancha Iliahs and charlatans of the like please.

» Multilingual Imperative
Posted by Pranjal Das on 2008-07-08 08:05:17.067346+05:30
I can't agree more. Failure to adopt English as a common medium of education is one of the great hypocrisies of modern India. The starting point for bridging the rural urban divide is to educate rural India in English medium

Shaadi Matrimonials
Get Marriage Proposals by Email EVERYDAY!
Register FREE on Naukri.com.
200000+ Hot Job Openings!
Yatra Offers
10% cash back on Master Card
Send Gifts
Flowers and Gifts
Express Classifieds
Post and view free classifieds ad
Express Astrology
Know what's in the stars for you