Blog cafe Open to immigration

Font Size

Print

Feedback

Email

Discuss

: A month ago, a BBC News investigation team uncovered a criminal network in West London, involved in smuggling poor, male farmers from Punjab in India into the UK. These illegal immigrants, were given fake documents, poorly paid manual work and stationed in squalid housing. Yes, it was totally wrong to provide them with fake passports, driving licenses and Home Office registration cards. But there are other aspects of this activity where the illegality is not so obvious, and they should be further contemplated before being branded so quickly as inhumane.

Take their pay—they are often employed for 12-hour days, six days a week at £150, which is just over £2 an hour. As rural workers in India pay, rights and living and working conditions are even worse. This is evident from the lengths they are willing to go to in order to enter Britain illegally. Poverty in India is improved by the remittances.

The UK also profits. In keeping within the laws of supply and demand, abundant labour brings down the costs of goods and services for the consumer. And with the need for manual labour taken care of, the UK can focus on becoming a knowledge-based economy.

Evidently, we need a pro-immigration policy, bringing non-zero sum consequences where both immigrants and the British benefit. The entry of 600,000 eastern Europeans since 2004 is testament to this; their role as workers and consumers has been vital to this country’s growth . Indeed, the Labour government’s decision to open its borders when the remainder of Europe (save Ireland and Sweden) refused to, is something to be commended. Let’s just hope it doesn’t stop there.