1. FM Arun Jaitley’s 5 point rebuttal to Rahul Gandhi’s ‘Arhar Modi’ and ‘Chowkidaar’ jibes

FM Arun Jaitley’s 5 point rebuttal to Rahul Gandhi’s ‘Arhar Modi’ and ‘Chowkidaar’ jibes

Finance Minister Arun Jaitley today gave a point-by-point rebuttal to Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi's barbs on price rise and inflation in the economy.

By: | Published: July 28, 2016 4:56 PM
Arun Jaitley attacks Rahul Gandhi, rahul gandhi arhar modi, rahul gandhi chowkidaar modi, rahul gandhi modi “Everybody in this house claims to be going to the market everyday,” Jaitley said in reply to Rahul Gandhi’s claim that the government is oblivious to the high rates of food and vegetables in the country.

Finance Minister Arun Jaitley today gave a point-by-point rebuttal to Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi’s barbs on price rise and inflation in the economy. “Everybody in this house claims to be going to the market everyday,” Jaitley said in reply to Rahul Gandhi’s claim that the government is oblivious to the high rates of food and vegetables in the country. Jaitley explained the reasons for the current prices of pulses, onions, tomatoes and sugar. He also questioned Rahul Gandhi’s “back of the envelope” calculation in suggesting that the entire benefit of low oil prices should have been passed on to the consumer. We take a look at what Jaitley said on each issue raised by Rahul Gandhi in the Parliament:

1) What comparison was being made by you (Rahul)? We inherited double-digit inflation from your government. Now it has come down to 5 to 6% levels. The current price rise is a seasonal effect that will get settled in the coming months. I expect that with good monsoon and harvest, prices of most food items will come down.

2) Countering Rahul Gandhi’s ‘Arhar Modi’ and ‘Chowkidaar’ jibe, Jaitley said, “I am not sure what new economic equation is being talked about. By your (Rahul’s) logic, the price of dal should rise, only if the MSP rises. I would like to tell you, in case you don’t know, that price is a function of demand and supply. Even after increasing the MSP of pulses, there is a supply deficit. The requirement is 23 million tonnes and the production has been 17 million tonne. Less production is a function of two consecutive years of poor monsoon. The deficit had to be imported. Hoarding happened and we cracked down on it. Now, we expect that with good monsoon, the production should be around 20 million tonne. This will help control prices of pulses.”

Also read: Rahul Gandhi’s new slogan for PM Modi: “Arhar Modi, Arhar Modi, Arhar Modi”

3) You (Congress) mentioned the prices of sugar. Let me tell you that till a few months back the price of sugar was Rs 22-23. This is a price at which farmers cannot make profit. They can make profit at levels of Rs 28-30. So Paswan ji was working on policies that made it viable for farmers to grow sugarcane. That was the worry of the government.

4) As far as onions and tomatoes are concerned, till a few months ago onion prices had crashed. People were throwing onions on the streets. Tomatoes were also at very low prices. The current rates are because of a seasonal rise in prices. This is a pre-monsoon effect. After the good monsoon, the production would ensure that prices stabilise at lower levels.

5) On the issue of passing on the benefit of low international crude oil prices, let me settle this once and for all. It would be great if back of the envelope calculations are not made by you (Rahul). The benefit of lower prices has been distributed in a three-fold manner; one, it has been passed on to consumers in the form of lower petrol and diesel prices; two, it went to loss-making oil marketing companies; three, it was used by the government for public investment. You have to understand that the cars the consumers drive also need better roads. Public investment is a crucial part of growth, and it is one of the biggest drivers of growth currently. Had all the benefit been passed on only to consumers, then we would have an economy that is stuck with low economic growth.

  1. K
    Kaminder Walia
    Jul 28, 2016 at 6:05 pm
    Fake peoples gives fake arguments, why they don't collect bad debts given to Modi friends? Why all inflation and cost of growth be owned by poor nd lower middle cl? Why health and education going out of bound of poor and middle cl? Why Mr Jaitley? Reply but u don't, we reply now in every coming elections. Just see
    Reply
    1. अण्णाजी
      Jul 28, 2016 at 12:09 pm
      and still it would be foolish to be sure that Shahzada understood everything what Jaitley explained.
      Reply
      1. A
        Ashok
        Jul 28, 2016 at 1:59 pm
        I think Rahul should go to study basics of economy and country fiscal situation.
        Reply
        1. coolguy hero
          Jul 28, 2016 at 3:21 pm
          from 5 points papu doesn't understand a single one.
          Reply
          1. R
            romi
            Jul 28, 2016 at 5:08 pm
            now what rahul ?pls next before questioning first get the answers as you are only good at questioning & afraid or disappear to avoid answers Man you need to first educate yourself
            Reply
            1. Harish Advani
              Jul 28, 2016 at 1:55 pm
              Exactly my feeling as well. How much of Mr Jaitley's reply and the points raised there in were understood and imbibed by Raul Vinci. This useless 'Man-Boy',claims to have achieved an MPhil in "Developmental Economics"!. It beggars belief how this man even had the temerity to ask the questions he did in the LS. MPs of such low intellect bring Parliament into disrepute and an insution to be mocked by the common man.
              Reply
              1. K
                kameswara rao
                Jul 28, 2016 at 1:18 pm
                Rahul is not even aware how many dals there. we just observed his speech closely. all that he wants to say is just i am interested in getting the PM by name and call with some sort of a slogan. he is desirous say, congress also can use a name or two for the PM. he should know that the former pm is called by certain name, because of the way he was allowed to function. if Rahul really wants to say something worth, he should learn the basics of economy and governance.
                Reply
                1. N
                  N.Shekar
                  Jul 29, 2016 at 9:54 pm
                  Sheer waste of time and energy trying to educate the immature, half Italian "NonSense" as nothoing will go into his head except drugs.
                  Reply
                  1. A
                    Asutosh
                    Jul 28, 2016 at 2:26 pm
                    Mr Jaitley donot show figures you yourself know the price of pulses specifically arhar dal has increases 4 times since you and your Government in power.It pinches us.Do really something about it and others pulses prices.You can outsmart by giving outsmart answers and fact you cannot deny it hurts do genuinely do something for this
                    Reply
                    1. Sri Aiyer Raju Sreenivasan
                      Jul 29, 2016 at 3:07 pm
                      Brilliant. But it requires minimum understanding power. Doess Pappu have it?
                      Reply
                      1. Load More Comments

                      Go to Top