MPV players: Toyota Innova 2.5 Z vs Tata Aria 4x4 Pride

Updated: Jan 4 2014, 17:18pm hrs
Toyota Innova-Tata AriaToyota Innova comes with a decent amount of features but the Aria 4x4 is actually even better equipped.
Toyota has updated its best-selling Innova, but the price has shot up too. It looks like a good match for the super-capable but often overlooked Tata Aria:

Whats new

The Toyota Innova has been in the Indian market for quite some time. It was first launched here in 2005 and this is its third facelift. Customers, however, are still lapping it up and Toyota sells an average of 4,800 Innovas a month. But with fresher competition having hit our market over the past few years, the Innovas sales have seen a slight decline, which explains why Toyota has tried to keep things fresh and introduced this facelift. The most noticeable change is the massive three-slat chrome grille and the fog lamp surrounds, also layered with chrome. Theres a big chrome strip that runs along the sides, but the rear is pretty much unchanged, save for some chrome garnish on the boot.

The very capable Aria is a car we really like, and its a real shame that Tatas MPV got off to such a poor start. It is one of the most comfortable cars in its class (more so on long drives), its bigger than the Innova and this translates to acres of room inside, its got a powerful yet frugal 2.2-litre diesel engine, and its built to be tough. With the Innovas prices headed skyward, the top-of-the-line Z trim that were driving is only R3,000 cheaper than the fully-loaded Tata Aria 4x4 Pride, which is priced at R15.10 lakh. The question is, does the Tata Aria deserve a second look at this price, or is the Innova still good enough

What are they like to drive

The Innova is the nicer to drive of the two, especially in the city. The clutch and steering are light and easy to use. In fact, it feels almost like a mid-size saloon to drive, despite its size. The Toyotas larger engine coupled with its lighter body means that its quicker to respond to your right foot, which is useful, especially in traffic; its easy to slot the car into gaps between cars. At high speeds, its stable and quite comfortable too and the suspension does a good job of absorbing the rough stuff. However, with a full load, the Innova does tend to bob a bit on the highway. The Innovas engine is also the more vocal of the two, and the noise and lack of power are something youll definitely notice when youre driving fast. Another grouse we had is with the long-throw gear lever; though nice to slot, it looks and feels a bit tacky in a car like this.

Start the Aria up and youll notice that the engine feels quite refinedits much quieter than the Innovas 2.5-litre unit, and the car is also the quieter of the two on the move. The one were driving is the 4x4 variant, but theres a small button that changes it to 4x2 mode, and this sends power only to the rear wheels, which improves fuel efficiency. In 4x4 mode, whenever the car is short on grip, the engine can send up to 45% of its power to the front wheels, but you will rarely find need to use this mode in everyday driving situations. The Aria is 200mm longer than the Innova, so naturally, parking it in the city is a task on its own. And although the Aria is quite nice to drive, the gearbox, clutch and steering arent of the same quality or as light to use as the Innovas.

Ride & handling

Both these cars are huge MPVs, so theyre going to handle like big MPVs. The Aria has more body roll when you take it round a corner quickly, while the Innova feels a bit more composed and points into corners well. Once you get used to the roll on the Aria, however, it drives really well too, giving the driver plenty of confidence from the hydraulic power assisted steering wheel.

The Aria even drives well when fully loaded; the suspension soaks up bumps well and little of it can be felt in the cabin. And despite having a smaller engine, the Aria is quicker to 100 kph than the Innova by 1.84 seconds. The Toyotas engine produces less overall power and as a result cant hold on to high speeds for prolonged periods.

What are they like inside

The Toyotas cabin holds on to its airy feel, and to justify the premium, theres a new faux wood finish on the armrests and gear knob and hints of chrome on the dash, which lift the ambience of the cabin. The steering wheel is the same as the one on the Corolla and the fit and finish and overall feel of the buttons and wheel are solid. In fact, the entire dashboard feels solidly built. Even on older Innovas in the second-hand market, the dashboards look and feel new after years of use. So theres no doubting that this cars insides are built to last.

This top-spec Z version of the Innova is a new trim in the range and it comes only with individual captain seats for the middle row. However, the lower variants have the option of a conventional bench instead. The seats are very comfortable, especially on long drives, but the third row is a little lacking in thigh support and is best suited for children. The middle row is adjustable and can be moved forward to liberate more room for the third-row passengers. Legroom for the middle row is good, but the Aria is more spacious thanks to its longer wheelbase and overall length.

The Innova comes equipped with a very useful rear-view camera that uses the touchscreen infotainment system as a display, but the lack of parking sensors means that you cant afford to take your eyes off the screen.

Step into the Aria and the cabin, though airy, doesnt feel as premium as the Toyotas. There are nice bits though, like the air-con vents that are neatly integrated into the dash within the faux wood panels. However, the entire dash doesnt feel as solid as the Innovas. The Arias steering-mounted controls feel flimsy and you often end up pressing them when youre turning the wheel. The Aria is huge, so its a good thing it has parking sensors, which are quite effective, and since our test car is the now-discontinued 4x4 Pleasure variant, it doesnt come with a reversing camera. The top 4x4 Pride variant, however, does get a camera. The air-con unit, though effective on the whole, doesnt do as good a job cooling the front two seats as the Innovas unit, so if youre driving on a hot summers day, youre going to feel a little uncomfortable in the Aria.

The Aria comes with a second row bench and not captain seats. You sit higher in the Innova than in the Aria, but thigh support in the Tata is better, and its third row seats are comfier, especially on long drives. The Aria has lots of useful roof-mounted storage areas, more than you could have asked for in fact.

Overall, where the Innova trumps the Aria is clearly quality. The Tata just doesnt feel as well put together as the Toyota, which is possibly what puts some quality-conscious buyers off.

Equipment & safety

The Innova comes with a decent amount of features. Its got a colour touchscreen with Bluetooth, aux and USB connectivity that doubles up as the reversing camera monitor. Other features include keyless entry, steering-mounted audio controls, drivers seat height adjustment and two airbags. The Aria 4x4 is actually even better equipped. Theres satellite navigation, cruise control, electrically adjustable wing mirrors, drivers seat height adjustment, rain-sensing wipers, a cooled glovebox and a total of six airbags. Its also got ABS and disc brakes for all four wheels; the Innova uses drum brakes at the rear.

The face-lifted Toyota Innova is available in three trimsG, V and Zand two configurations, a seven-seater and eight-seater (the Z is only a seven-seater). All of these versions are available only as diesels, but if you really want the petrol, it can be built to order.

The Tata Aria is available in three configurations4x2 Pure, 4x2 Pleasure and 4x4 Pride. Do keep in mind that Tata is trying hard to sell more Arias, so there are usually very tempting discounts on offer.

Aria 4x4 Pride

Engine and performance

Size: 2179cc, 4 cylinders

Peak power: 138bhp@4000rpm

Peak torque: 32.6kgm@2700rpm

0-100 kph: 15.66 seconds

Top speed: 171 kph

Economy: 11.8 kpl overall

Tank: 60 litres

Range: 708 km

Innova 2.5 Z

Engine and performance

Size: 2494cc, 4 cylinders

Peak power: 102bhp@3600rpm

Peak torque: 20.4kgm@3400rpm

0-100 kph: 17.50 seconds

Top speed: 146 kph

Economy: 12.05 kpl overall

Tank: 55 litres

Range: 665 km