Mixed response to cent percent cut-offs in Delhi University

Written by Press Trust of India | New Delhi | Updated: Jul 2 2014, 02:47am hrs
JobsThe first cut-off list of Delhi University for its undergraduate courses touching the 100 per cent mark today evoked mixed response from students and academicians.
The first cut-off list of Delhi University for its undergraduate courses touching the 100 per cent mark today evoked mixed response from students and academicians.

Defending the cent percent cut-off, Sriram College of Commerce Principal P C Jain said "we are moving in the right direction but we are not appreciating it. Their is a wave of zero tolerance for defects across the world in all sectors, so we need to train our students to be 100 per cent perfect. Our students are performing well but we are viewing this spirit of competition in negative light. "

"The world appreciates merit but why should we appreciate nepotism Rather than seeing high cut-offs negatively, we should see them as benchmarks of healthy competition which is paving its way towards excellence," he added.

Pratibha Jolly, Principal, Miranda House, however, chose to differ on the concept of '100 per cent' cut-off and said "the practice leads to a category of students being ruled out from choosing a particular subject."

"We have set a calibrated cut-off based on our past experiences and we have already filled one-fifth of our seats today. Despite high cut offs, the seats do get filled but students don't really have a choice," she said.

"Its a national failure that we don't have a good admission policy in place. Since, marks are the only helpful indicators in the absence of rigorous ways of evaluating an individual, students have no choice rather than the race for scoring more for securing admission," added Jolly.

S K Gupta, Deen Dayal Upadhyaya College Principal and President of DU's Principals' Association, described the cut- offs as 'exaggerated'.

"I believe the colleges are trying to play safe with these exaggerated cut-offs. No doubt, the competition is high but the cut-offs are expected to come down in further lists," he said.

"The marking pattern at CBSE is also equally responsible for these cut-offs. Since leniency in marking leads to an 'inflation' of marks in board exams, 'exaggerated' cut-offs are bound to be witnessed," added Gupta.

However, students seemed angry over the high cut-offs.

A group of students under the banner of Krantikari Yuva Sangathan today staged protest at Art Faculty of North Campus, demanding the cut-off be brought down.

Protestors raised slogans - "cut-off ghatao, seat badhao" and burnt the first cut-off list released by colleges of Delhi University.

The admission season at Delhi University finally took off today after week-long uncertainty due to the row over the four-year undergraduate programme (FYUP) with students queueing up at various colleges in large numbers.

DU announced a high cut-off list post midnight for admission to undergraduate courses under three-year format with three rank outsider colleges setting the maximum bar of 100 per cent for B.Sc (Honours) Computer Science course.

With admissions a week behind schedule, students seemed eager to get themselves enrolled in the colleges of their choice and are quite relieved that the row between University Grants Commission and the varsity over FYUP had ended.

According to fresh admission guidelines issued by DU, students who have registered for the current academic year will be eligible for admission to all courses wherever they meet the criteria. Over 2.7 lakh students applied this year for admission to 54,000 seats in 64 colleges.

Giving another chance to those students who had missed the deadline to fill application forms, the varsity has allowed them to take admission by filling the university registration form along with the college admission form.

Acharya Narendra Dev, Atma Ram Sanatan Dharma and Shyama Prasad Mukherjee College have posed a stiff competition with its 100 per cent cut-off for the computer science honours course for students who have studied Arts in Class XII.

Most colleges have announced cut-offs above 90 per cent.

In reaction to the sky-high cut-offs, author Chetan Bhagat tweeted this morning saying, "A 100% cut-off doesn't tell you the college is good. It tells you something is really, really wrong with our education system."

The 100 per cent cut-off for B.Tech (Computer Science) at Ram Lal Anand College last year and for B.Com (Hons) at SRCC in 2011 had sparked a major outcry.