Instead of all this, however, finance secretary RS Gujral wrote to the Empowered Group of Ministers (when Pranab Mukherjee was the finance minister) saying that states would not be paid any CST compensation from 2011-12 onwards, and that the compensation for 2010-11 would be restricted to the R6,394 crore that had already been paid. By appointing two separate committees, one for CST and one for GST design, finance minister P Chidambaram has chosen to be both pragmatic as well as fairthe states have genuine issues and the only way GST can move forward is with the states agreeing to this. Considerable progress has already been made in terms of the states agreeing that all but a negative list of services can be taxed, and in setting up the GST network which is the nuts and bolts of the electronic system that will power GST. Perhaps the Centre will also agree to the other demands of the statesto do away with the GST council headed by the FM and bring in place an appellate tribunal to settle tax disputes. This may be the perfect solution, but if the Empowered Group of Minister-system worksand it did give us the VATit may be pragmatic to let it be for now, let the GST roll out for a few years, and then take a call on how essential this is.